>> |
No. 29361
>>29350
I think what it actually comes down to, for me, is that they keep saying that the people are dead. We knew from the beginning that the old gas from the bomb took some time to work, which is why they needed to make it solidify people in the first place. I would have accepted a race to save everyone if it was clearly established as such. However, because everyone is going DEAD DEAD DEAD it changes the issue from a race against time to find and implement a cure to "Oda, not this shit again." The difference between "THEY'RE DEAD oh wait never mind" and "HOW WILL THEY SURVIVE oh, like that" is small but, in a story like this, really important. I guess if I had to answer your question I would be ok with the following scenarios:
1. After establishing that shinokuni can be cured, everyone is cured after a crazy and awesome sequence. Classic OP. 2. After establishing that shinokuni can be cured, most people are saved but they can't get to all of them in time. Sad but effective. 3. After establishing that everyone shinokuni touches dies, everyone that touches shinokuni dies. Tough but fair. You gotta follow through with your threats or else your audience isn't going to believe you.
Like, lets look at Bon Clay. He didn't die on screen. Everyone thought he died, and he made a dramatic speech and everything, but there was still a possibility that he could have escaped alive. So, when he did, I went oh cool, he survived after all! But then there is stuff like Skypeia where it's established that "unable to be heard with mantra=dead." There are a few loopholes like Luffy's thing with the snake, but overall the rule held fast. So when mantra master Enel pronounced someone dead, they should have been dead! Those were the rules Oda set up. But everyone lived. It's like, why did you lie to me Oda? The story would be worse if they were just unconscious, so why the lies?
ENOUGH BITCHING MANGASTREAM IS OUT http://mangastream.com/read/one_piece/40412356/1
|