/a/ Avatar Archived Board plus4chan home [baw] [co/cog/jam/mtv] [coc/draw/diy] [pco/coq/cod] [a/mspa/op/pkmn] [Burichan/Futaba/Greygren]
[Return] [Entire Thread] [Last 50 posts] [First 100 posts]
Posting mode: Reply
Name
Email
Subject   (reply to 112202)
Message
File
Password  (for post and file deletion)

Currently 0 unique user posts.

News
  • 08/21/12 - Poll ended; /cod/ split off as a new board from /pco/.

File 137013441459.png - (566.58KB , 750x419 , Untitled.png )
112202 No. 112202
Doug Walker (AKA The Nostalgia Critic) has decided to review Syamalan's masterpiece, but he wants to come at it knowing about the source material, so he's going to be watching the entire series, one episode per night, and posing his reactions and thoughts in video form. As a big fan of his work (less so since his comeback) and of his reviews, I'm super excited and can't wait to see his thoughts.

http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39420-the-last-airbender-vlogs

Who will be watching with me?
Expand all images
>> No. 112203
Whoa! The NC stuff has inevitably gotten a little stale, but I won't miss this.
>> No. 112204
can someone hotlink them in this thread plz?
>> No. 112205
I've never really seen the point of professional review videos.
>> No. 112206
You have my attention.
>> No. 112207
Hopefully this'll be better then the crap that was Disneycember and Dreamworksuary
>> No. 112209
>>112204
I'm sure they'll be posted under the "Specials" section of his site.

http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials
>> No. 112212
File 137015863874.png - (283.80KB , 442x628 , 1356567796132.png )
112212
I'm looking forward to this with optimism. Cautious optimism. But I'm sure he'll enjoy the series overall. I just dread what will happen when he gets around to reviewing the Crime Against Cinema that is the movie. I'm picturing the "Horribifuckus" montage from when he tried to watch TMNT 3, which was pretty much the first thing that popped into my head when I saw clips from ShamWow's TLA.
>> No. 112215
A review of each episode could be interesting. I wonder if he'll complain about the gaps that were filled by the comics (in the cartoons the Earth King just sort of disappears, while in the comics they explain that he's on a journey to learn about the world).
>> No. 112216
>>112215

Sokka mentions that in Season 3, actually.
>> No. 112217
Sounds fun.

If anyone's hungry for something similar, I'd recommend the recap SF Debris did of Korra's first season. It covered all the bases.

http://sfdebris.com/videos/animation/lok.asp
>> No. 112218
IT BEGINS

http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39436-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-boy-in-the-iceberg
>> No. 112220
Someone ought to tell him some of the episodes are supposed to be watched back to back
>> No. 112221
>>112205
>I've never really seen the point of professional review videos.
I can't speak for others, but I just enjoy listening to people's opinions when they know how to voice them.

>>112218
I love how he pegs Iroh's entire character in the first episode. That's the sign of a well-written and well-acted role.
>> No. 112222
File 137023524415.png - (301.53KB , 289x533 , punkdrugs.png )
112222
>>112220

>He only watched half of the premiere

D'oh!
>> No. 112224
>>112203
This.
I'll stick around.

>>112207
And hey! I liked those.

Hell, those are the reason why he's doing these anyway.
He started out Disneycember. Then did it again, then noticed how Profitable december was views-wise.
Being the main draw to the site, people checked back ever day. Giving the site pagevisits, increasing the value of advertising space, and increasing ad revenue.
Then did it again with dreamworks, and now he's doing this.
An just as established franchise with alot of content and a strong and large fanbase.
Don't be surprised if once he's done he starts thinking about doing homestuck.

Frankly, the guy is a pretty savvy businessguy when it comes to internet stuff.
>> No. 112225
I liked the review of the first one, and that he seems to be approaching it was a more open mind than I've seen some people use.

Some people just hate the show on principle due to it either "ripping off anime" or "being an anime" regardless of the actual content. Both arguements are stupid.

Looking forward to the rest, is it a daily thing or a weekly thing?

>>112203

I'm not sure about stale, but the new episodes do seem to have more genuine resentment behind them than the previous ones. Like before you could tell he was playing a character, but now it seems more like Doug himself is getting kind of sick of things.

Or maybe he's just that good an actor, I don't know. I've liked some of the renewed stuff, but I thought that the character had a good ending with TBF and the rest, honestly.
>> No. 112228
>>112224
When Doug did Disneycember, he missed the damn point of why Monster Madness was so appealing. James Rolfe actually knew his shit about the history of horror and had this passion for it that made it interesting to watch the series and you'd actually learn something from it. Disneycember basically amounted to bland "I like this, I don't like this, this was mediocre, the animation was colorful" comments, offering no unique insight and it ended up being pretty meh.
>> No. 112230
It's been a while since I've seen someone watch the series with a fresh outlook. Personally I always thought season 1 takes a while to get started so it'll be interesting to see his take on it. Someone should also tell him the movie is only based on S1.

>>112228
When he did Disneycember you could tell he was actually excited, and was tapping into his own nostalgia of the older movies. But during the Dreamworks reviews he sounded more like a parent who had just seen the films, just mentioning what was funny or good for kids.
>> No. 112232
>>112225
>Looking forward to the rest, is it a daily thing or a weekly thing?
He says he'll post a video every night whenever he's able to. He has to travel a lot for cons and such, so don't be surprised if he misses a couple of days.

If it was weekly, it would take about a year to get through the whole series.
>> No. 112238
next one is up.
>> No. 112239
>>112238

It's only the second video, but I'm getting a bit annoyed that he's not referring to the characters by name.
>> No. 112240
File 137031901853.jpg - (3.18KB , 190x200 , RVD_WAT.jpg )
112240
I want to choke some of the idiots in the comments

> avatar
Sokka and Aang have always been my least liked characters. As Doug points out humor is very hit-or-miss and Sokka - at least to me - is full of miss. He's meant to be the comic relief but a lot of the time he's just annoying. His slapstick antics constantly raise the question; "what purpose do you serve in this group?" I'll give the writers this though; as the series progressed he actually became less useless, though still unfunny.

>Aang is boring. Typical god-hero, his character arc ultimately boiling down to "will he discover how perfect he is before the final battle," the answer to which is pretty obvious since it's a kids show. Obviously he's not going to lose. It's up to the writers to make the character interesting despite how transparent his journey is, but because they've already established him as an all around good person there aren't many places his arc can go. Zuko is far more interesting, as Doug will find as he further delves into the series.

This person is too fucking stupid to live- hey wait a second!

>username: KaizerJED

Is this...is this Serial Kiffer? The same shithead behind the OMG GRIMDARK AU that was secretly dedicated to the Insane Clown Posse?
>> No. 112241
>>112240
>Sokka and Aang have always been my least liked characters.
In that case, you have a bad opinion.
>> No. 112244
>>112228
Sure.
But in the end, this guy's working for profit.

James Rolf has as well, but..
He's always felt more authentic. Doing stuff out of love for videogames, film making...
I don't wanna pass judgement on this guy, but he just seems to roll with whatever brings in cash.
>> No. 112245
>>112241
Well no shit, it's Serial Kiffer. He's like...objectively wrong. As a person.
>> No. 112250
http://blip.tv/nostalgiacritic/the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-avatar-returns-6597046
As expected, he's now hooked.
>> No. 112252
Gooooood.

It's going to make the review kind of hilarious when the internal logic of the show was lost somewhere in the making of the movie.

Such as the prison episode. Or the natural relationship growth of Sokka/Yue.
>> No. 112253
*When the review shows how the internal logic and character progression was lost, I mean, Argh.
>> No. 112254
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39465-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-southern-air-temple

The agni kai in this episode is one of my all-time favorite moments in this series. So glad he loved it for all the same reasons I did.

I do, however, fear that he's setting himself up for a bit of a letdown when he gets to the slower episodes of this season. It's not all amazing, Doug. It's never bad, but it does stray from amazing from time to time.
>> No. 112255
>>112254

The high points of the first half of the season are the premier, the Southern air temple, imprisoned and the winter solstice two-parter.

He has enough to keep him going until he hits the storm ,and it's mostly up from there.
>> No. 112256
>8 years since the show premiered.

man I feel old.
>> No. 112257
>honor
He gets it!
>> No. 112258
>>112255
The Blue Spirit's pretty good, too.
>> No. 112259
>>112254
Should someone warn him about "The Great Divide"?

Like just tell him to skip it, or close his eyes and mute the show and think of something else for 22 minutes?
>> No. 112260
>>112259

No lie, that was my very first Avatar episode and it's not absolutely horrible, (though being unfamiliar with the series at the time, I had thought Aang wasn't totally human, thus the "I may not look it but I'm 112 years old!")
>> No. 112261
>>112260
Honestly, I liked it better than The Beach.
>> No. 112262
>>112259
I swear to God I'm the only person who genuinely loves that episode.

It's not the best episode by any means, but I like it.
>> No. 112263
>>112259
The Great Divide is far from terrible - mediocre, and not up the general quality of the rest of the show, but it's blown out of proportion.

It's worth watching through the first time, at least, and skipping if you find it dull.
>> No. 112264
>>112260
Same thing here, The Great Divide was the first episode. It makes a good case for showing off different animation styles and the different kind of peoples in the Avatar world.

I know people hate The Great Divide but at least to me, they seem to exaggerate the flaws in the episode.
>> No. 112265
>>112225
>Some people just hate the show on principle due to it either "ripping off anime" or "being an anime" regardless of the actual content. Both arguements are stupid.

They're also ironic because the anime style was based on old Disney cartoons.
>> No. 112266
The Great Divide gets loads of hate because the series was on a hiatus and it's the only episode they showed for a stretch of several weeks.
>> No. 112268
As a person whose very first episode of AtLA was The Great Divide, I'll just say that that episode put me off the show for about two years before my friends managed to convince me to give AtLA another try.

So yeah, it's that bad.
>> No. 112270
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39473-the-last-airbender-vlogs-warriors-of-kyoshi

Foamy Mouth Guy claims another fan.
>> No. 112271
File 137057327836.jpg - (100.19KB , 930x478 , Avatar__crazy_foamy_guy_by_rufftoon.jpg )
112271
Foamy get's the creed he deserves.
>> No. 112273
File 137057422368.jpg - (26.48KB , 299x419 , 1310709622073.jpg )
112273
>He is liking it a lot

>He has to review the movie.

He found Avatar, but at what cost...
>> No. 112274
>>112270
Wow, Avatar brings families together. That's sweet.

>>112273
His rage in approximately two months will be delicious. It will likely dwarf anything James Rolfe has managed to produce.
>> No. 112275
Now that I realize, the naming of the creatures was pretty inconsistent in the beginning.

When did the half/half mixture establish itself?
>> No. 112276
File 13705806255.jpg - (8.10KB , 200x193 , katara_dowant.jpg )
112276
>>112270

GOT 'EM
>> No. 112277
To be honest, I never much liked Warriors of Kiyoshi. I found the girl power subplot rather irritating. But Doug does make a good point in how it's handled better than in other works. I'm glad he enjoyed it.

The only possible stumbling blocks from here to the season finale are The Great Divide and The Fortuneteller. Think he'll find a way to sail over those as being good in some way? I never hated The Great Divide, despite it's superfluousness, but the whole Reason vs. Faith debate in The Fortuneteller was pretty annoying.
>> No. 112278
>he doesn't get the lettuce leaf joke

I am appalled and disappointed.
>> No. 112279
>>112278
What kind of wizard are you, I don't even see it up on the site yet?
>> No. 112280
>>112279
Takes time to set up the embed on their main site.

http://blip.tv/nostalgiacritic/the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-king-of-omashu-6599349
>> No. 112281
>>112280
Well... ok, but I still think your some kind of dark wizard regardless.
>> No. 112282
Well, hopefully he'll watch the Winter Solstice together, since it's says part 1 and 2 on the very title.
>> No. 112283
http://blip.tv/nostalgiacritic/the-last-airbender-vlogs-imprisoned-6599967
>> No. 112289
File 137076254984.jpg - (50.18KB , 960x541 , duhhoii.jpg )
112289
>>112283

>He's getting all 3 main character's names down
>He fucking loves Geroge Takei's character and performance
>He loves the episode
>He's getting sucked in, a happy sucked in, not a depressing 'Game of Thrones' kind of sucked in

Good Goodyoutube thumb
>> No. 112297
http://blip.tv/nostalgiacritic/the-last-airbender-vlogs-winter-solstice-1-2-6600336
>> No. 112298
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39507-the-last-airbender-vlogs-winter-solstice-1-a-2
>> No. 112300
File 137083883579.jpg - (7.60KB , 177x278 , ohbaby.jpg )
112300
>he watched both parts of the two parter

He's learning.
>> No. 112302
File 137084005761.gif - (1.26MB , 163x200 , 1370486478492.gif )
112302
>dat observance of the directing of the closing shot of part 2

Delectable.

gif attached is a response for this dumb-as-rocks commentor

>Blizzard185 - To Freyzi:
>The ONLY episode I don't like watching out of this entire show was the Season 3 episode "Ember Island Players".

>hating the most glorious episode of the series
>> No. 112303
File 137084135089.png - (1.03MB , 1280x720 , vlcsnap-2013-06-09-03h31m02s245.png )
112303
>>112289
Higher quality:
>> No. 112304
>>112300
To be fair, the first two episodes weren't listed as Part 1 and Part 2.
>> No. 112321
File 137095014118.png - (526.02KB , 720x576 , phf.png )
112321
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39521-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-waterbending-scroll

>"So the lemur can fly? When was that a thing?"
>my face
>> No. 112324
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39528-the-last-airbender-vlogs-jet
>> No. 112334
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39537-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-great-divide
weeeeeeelp
>> No. 112335
>>112334

>8+ minutes railing on the ending of the episode

Really? THAT is what turned him off in the Great Divide? REALLY?
>> No. 112337
File 137113569572.jpg - (172.97KB , 940x746 , PutYourHandsUp.jpg )
112337
Hey! Why doesn't Imprisoned get jazz hands in it's thumbnail preview like all the rest!?
>> No. 112338
>The storm is up next

I predict a 20+ min video.
>> No. 112341
File 137114115567.png - (649.19KB , 720x540 , vlcsnap-2011-10-14-01h47m06s212.png )
112341
>>112334
Some people are still butthurt about their parents lying to them a long long time ago, and just cannot get over it. That's why so many people disliked the episode. Mommy lied to be about Santa! Waaaaaaah!

To be fair, ^that IS something to be upset about.

In defense of the episode, I just cannot see the conflict getting resolved any other way. It is clear that both tribes only care about what happened in the past. The don't want to move on, they don't want to forget. Their lives are controlled by their tradition and myths. Kind of reminds me of americans always debating over just what "the founding fathers" wanted. Since they could only stop fighting if a myth from their past told them so, Aang made one up.

tl;dr they were too stupid to accept the truth, so Aang had to use his trollbending (probably taught to him by Gyatso)
>> No. 112342
Nowhere it says the Avatar has to be perfect. Being human is about making mistakes and learning from it.

Remember when Aang stole a map showing Hakoda's fleet meeting point?
>> No. 112343
>>112342
Then there was that time he raped and killed a girl in 1990... oh wait, that was Glenn Beck.
>> No. 112345
>>112335

Ikr? That was one of the few things I actually liked about that episode (backgrounds, creature design, and the canyon guide being the others). The ending joke was actually pretty funny and I thought helped highlight just how bullshit and stupid their feud was.

In fact, the main reason I don't like this episode is that it all feels so blatant and preachy. Leaving Aang's story as true would have just given it an even worse pre-school lesson time feel.

I don't want to have my only comment on this stuff negative, so I'll say I'm really actually enjoying these vlogs. He's usually really insightful about the show and has noted some things I never really thought about. Plus it's really fun to watch his enthusiasm. I'm a little surprised to tell the truth since I got sick of his Nostalgia Critic stuff forever ago (though I'm guessing his NC review of TLA will be amazing).
>> No. 112346
I wonder if he'll keep going on through to Korra.
>> No. 112347
>>112346
It's still too early to tell, but let's hope he does.
>> No. 112351
>>112335
Heh Doug can't handle fables can he.

>>112346
Wonder if the more modern type setting would pull him out.
>> No. 112352
Oh Doug, how much are you going to suffer in the crossroads of destiny.
>> No. 112353
http://blip.tv/nostalgiacritic/the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-storm-6602364

>"There's one character especially when the uncles watching.. ...and there's this one girl in the front, I think there gonna make her a character, I'd be shocked if they didn't because she's just too well designed, and she just has this look, this evil little smile..."

Oh Doug, I'm now heavily anticipating you getting to that scene at the very end of the first season season.
>> No. 112355
>>112353
wonder what he'll think of the beach episode.
>> No. 112357
>>112353
Good God this guys fans are shitty. Doug makes mention of noticing that girl with the grin during the Agni Kai and half the comments are...

>OMG!!!! That's Azula!! THat's totally Zuko's sister who shows up a the end of the season and is the bad guy from season 2 on, and let me give you the rest of her bio and lay out all the plot points for which she's involved!!!

The fuck?
>> No. 112358
>>112357

Christ. Now I totally get Mark's spoiler-Nazi approach when he did his reviews.

Like a huge part of the fun of this is seeing his reaction to stuff as a newcomer. Why would they want to ruin that by telling him everything that happens? Luckily he said in his intro that he wasn't going to read many comments.
>> No. 112361
http://blip.tv/nostalgiacritic/the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-blue-spirit-6602896
I love how he guessed Azula's importance and age but was completely clueless about the Blue Spirit's identity.
>> No. 112362
>>112361
>Blue Demon

He's not kidding, he really is terrible at remembering episode names.
>> No. 112364
File 137126889468.gif - (955.02KB , 294x195 , stabbystab.gif )
112364
>>112361

>people in the comments calling The Fortunteller a filler episode

Get fucked with a rusty chainsaw pls
>> No. 112365
>>112364
There's this thing on the internet, where armchair critics have heard the term "filler" and don't really understand what it means, so they apply it willy-nilly even where it doesn't apply, like they do with Mary Sue and Hipster, to the point that it becomes meaningless. Really, outside of an work that's an adaptation from one medium to another, it's "filler" isn't really a thing that can exist.

But even if it were, it's not supposed to refer to episodes that advance a character's emotional arc or provide reduced tension for the sake of pacing and characterization. If it were, you would have to refer to pretty much the entirety of Cowboy Bebop as "filler," since there are only about four "plot" episodes in the entire series. That is not how filler works. Filler is supposed to have no relation to the rest of the work. Even if the only effect that an episode has is that it foreshadows something that happens later, or sets the audience's expectations about how a character behaves so that a later character moment has the appropriate amount of emotional torque, it's not filler.

Sometimes the fact that "nothing happens" (which is impossible, but people who focus on plot over character have a bad habit of not being able to see the forest for the trees) is important to the story that's being told.
>> No. 112366
File 137127608414.png - (1.24MB , 1280x720 , vlcsnap-2013-06-15-01h56m35s66.png )
112366
>>112361
And 3 more.
>> No. 112367
File 137127617086.png - (1.17MB , 1280x720 , vlcsnap-2013-06-15-01h58m21s204.png )
112367
>>112366
>> No. 112368
File 137127621735.png - (1.31MB , 1280x720 , vlcsnap-2013-06-15-01h59m09s140.png )
112368
>>112367
>> No. 112369
File 13712762755.png - (1.22MB , 1280x720 , vlcsnap-2013-06-15-01h59m53s205.png )
112369
>>112368
>> No. 112374
File 137136312685.jpg - (97.45KB , 600x568 , critic unitinu.jpg )
112374
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39571-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-fortuneteller
>> No. 112382
He posts a new review every day. Why are you ppl so slow?
>> No. 112387
>>112382
Hold yer damn horses, Mister...

http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39583-the-last-airbender-vlogs-bato-of-the-water-tribe

So apparently he didn't think The Great Divide was that bad (apart from the ending), but Bato of the Water Tribe was the first episode he didn't really like. Admittedly, the conflict between the Gaang members in this episode is a little contrived, but as Doug himself likes to point out, they are still kids.
>> No. 112393
>>112387
I'm not really a big fan of Bato of the Water Tribe either, but I absolutely love the fight scene between Aang and Zuko. It's the first time the two really spend an extended amount of time duking it out. The choreography is amazing and you can really see the clash of their personalities through their fighting style. Although it's sort of limiting, I really liked how the show made the connection between personality and fighting style so clear.
>> No. 112397
>>112387
It's because he hates anything with a Liar Revealed pllot.
>> No. 112399
File 137153766661.png - (294.00KB , 478x258 , DBry.png )
112399
>Liking most of The Great Divide aside from just the ending
>Hating Bato of the Water Tribe

ISHIGGYDIGGY
>> No. 112400
File 137153801674.jpg - (7.93KB , 195x258 , ruffleshaveridges.jpg )
112400
>thinking Bato just contrively 'switched sides' after the Gaang confict

Bato just put the gaang through a Rite of Passage to adulthood. He was treating the water sibs as equals, not as an authority figure.

Doug tends to let these things go right over his head. This rustles muh jimmies.
>> No. 112404
ok so why has it been silent for 3 days now?
>> No. 112408
File 137169868631.gif - (2.00MB , 389x157 , screamandpanic.gif )
112408
>>112404
HE SAW THE NEXT EPISODE AND HATED IT SO MUCH THAT HE CALLED OFF THE ENTIRE SERIES!
>> No. 112409
>>112408

>hating the deserter
>> No. 112421
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39631-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-deserter

Just kidding!
>> No. 112422
>having trouble understanding the healing bit.

man, doug is a bit thick sometimes.
>> No. 112424
>>112421

>calling this episode any sort of filler
>world building, character development, character introduction, more world building
>filler
>pick one

>not understanding why Aang wants to show off his fancy firebending skillz in front of Katara (hint, hint: it was in the fire festival scene you completely dismissed)

>not understanding at this point that Katara has innate waterbending talent but is completely ignorant of the art itself because GENOCIDE and a need of a teacher. Come on Doug!

>he still enjoyed it

Welp

Final stretch of book one, here we go!
>> No. 112425
>>112422
Yea he doesn't like to "read" when watching things.
>> No. 112428
ok its official this guy is not cut out for reviewing media. everything he likes is cliche and over done. and everything common sense based confuses the fuck out of him? i don't know if hes just not paying attention or if hes just dumb as a box of rocks. i know im gonna get hate for this but this guys a fucking tool he dismisses anything that tries to be original? but oh yeah he really likes the typical kiddie twist b.s. but snubs his nose at actual life lessons? yeah think i'm done with all this. im glad this might give the show more publicity but doug is a moron.

>out before STFU GTFO ect.
>> No. 112429
>>112428
I guess you just don't get it.
>> No. 112439
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39651-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-northern-air-temple
>> No. 112440
>>112424

In the latest review he said he did 3 episodes in a row, which might explain how he missed some stuff.
>> No. 112442
>>112439

>glowing review of the Northern Air Temple
>still feel the urge to label it as 'filler'

No.
>> No. 112443
>>112442
Filler episodes can still be perfectly good episodes.
>> No. 112445
>>112443

It's not filler, though. Not even by the colloquial "doesn't advance the plot" kind of definition.
>> No. 112449
>>112445
In retrospect? Of course not. At the time? Only the last minute hints at more than a Wacky Wayside Tribe thing.

Yes, I am salivating over his reaction to the next three eps.
>> No. 112452
>>112445
I was more attacking the idea that filler couldn't be good than I was supporting the idea that the Northern Air Temple is filler.
>> No. 112454
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39666-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-waterbending-master

Yeah, I always thought the sexism angle in this episode was pretty weak.
>> No. 112455
File 13719589483.gif - (358.21KB , 512x288 , dfs98df7sd1.gif )
112455
>>112454

Haven't even watched it yet and I'm doing this
>> No. 112456
File 137196050714.jpg - (154.85KB , 898x542 , Revolutionary_Girl_Katara_by_Isaia.jpg )
112456
>>112454

The lesson is a bit undermined by its resolution. Pakku doesn't take on Katara because of anything she says or does, but rather because of who her grandmother was. It's one of the rare things the 2005 story bible outline did better: in that, Katara simply proved her worth to Pakku in their duel through her iron will, and then later on his deathbed basically makes her his heir when it comes to teaching Aang.
>> No. 112458
>>112454

Okay, I have procured booze and I'm now watching

>Doug nails Penis Hair from TLA right off the bat

blammo

>GURL POWAH UGGGGHHH

It's like Doug still fears cooties or something. Frankly, I can't wait to see his reaction to 'the earthbender girl' (maybe he'll get Toph's name down instantly, who knows)

>Calling out Pakku on his duty to train god to save the planet from a firey apocalypse

Righto

>not understanding Katara's Rage Buttons this far into the series

Come on man, it's in the first friggin' scene of the show!

>Yukka: I'm sure there's gonna be more with that

You are not prepared.

>Aang and Katara are wise beyond their years

Alright, this video was much better than I feared. Time for hold on to our butts for the finale.
>> No. 112459
Oops, one major gripe

>He completely missed the subplot with Zuko, Zhao, and the swords

Ya (sorta) blew it. Maybe he'll call back to it when it comes up in the finale.
>> No. 112462
>>112458
>It's like Doug still fears cooties or something.
You don't have to fear cooties to be tired of a plot after seeing it a hundred times in as many stories. He even specifically said that the "girl power" plot from "The Warriors of Kyoshi" was done well because it was one guy with assumptions about gender roles who enters a culture that challenges those assumptions and changes his mind.

In this episode, we have the same old story; girl is told she can't fight even though she wants to, she proves how capable she is, and everybody who doesn't agree with her is labeled a bigot. Except they didn't even go that far in this story. Paku, by all indications, still thinks that women should stay in the healing room and only teaches Katara because he loved her grandmother.

Doug has no problem with strong female characters. He just finds it irritating when shows feel like they have to prove to us all over again that female characters can be strong.
>> No. 112463
>>112456

I liked the fact that they did that with Paku and Kana though.

People, particularly feminists, have this misconception that men who live in cultures where certain restrictions are imposed on women that aren't always done so on men hate their women or don't see them as people. I think it would have sucked if Paku wasn't in love with Katara's grandma because it would have just been Warriors of Kyoshi all over again.

Showing that softer side of Paku lets people know that he isn't some prick who dislikes women and is just trying to keep them from having fun or that he thinks of women as cattle who should fear the wrath of his iron testicles, he's just a guy who's been raised with the idea that a certain behavior is expected from the women of his society.
>> No. 112464
>>112462

See, I felt the exact opposite. I've never really liked "The Warriors of Kyoshi" because it felt too pandering, but I loved "The Waterbending Master" because it deals more with how culture causes sexism. I like that Katara didn't reach Pakku through just proving herself to be talented because sometime even if a woman is incredibly talented she's still written off because of her gender. Ultimately she gets her point through by her relation to her grandmother. It isn't that Pakku loved Kanna that made him change his mind; it's that he lost Kanna all those years ago due to the sexist culture he's still upholding.
>> No. 112465
>>112454
I don't.
>> No. 112467
>>112456
At the time (and now), I wondered how much of the "I'm doing this in Kanna's memory" was face-saving rationalization on Pakku's part. The Waterbending Grand Master of the Northern Tribe had to exert himself in a confrontation with a wholly self-trained 14 year old girl in _public_. With more than a few of the local womenfolk cheering her on. At the bare minimum there are going to be enough other students getting cajoled into pulling the same stunt Aang tried to force the elders to turn a blind eye.

One other point, the idea that Healing is the Proper Noble Art would hold more weight if the men were not so openly dismissive about the matter (of course in practical terms it would make sense to cross-train them anyway so the front-line fighters could patch each other up and the medics could help to guard their patients).
>> No. 112475
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39674-the-last-airbender-vlogs-siege-of-the-north

Pressing play right now
>> No. 112476
>implying there was a love triangle to begin with

Nope. Went right over your head dude. To steal from Azula, don't flatter yourself Doug, Hahn was never even a player.

>implying said love triangle 'ended in tragedy'

Yue's sacrifice was for her People and not for any man, despite how horrible it was for Sokka to be present for it. Saying it's due to some love triangle takes away from Yue's agency. Bad Doug, Bad!

>Koh is a caterpillar/spider with a vagina that spits out different faces

I lol'd

>completely missing HOW Koh steals faces and why Aang is acting as deadpan as possible

FUCKING FACEPALM. The single greatest line from …youtube thumb

>Firebenders get their power from the sun, that makes sense but waterbenders get their power from the moon? Huh because maybe it makes water colder?

FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU

F- SEE ME AFTER CLASS.

Doug needs to rewatch the fucking finale. Seriously.
>> No. 112477
>confused about Yue and the spirits

Protip: Rewatch the goddamn episode!

This latest video is beyond fucking disappointing. I'm getting second hand embarrassment over here.
>> No. 112478
I hope Doug reads this comment:

>Doug, I'm starting to stop enjoying these, it's just too frustrating to see you skipping over major plot points, suddenly forgetting about them and then saying that the episode doesn't make sense, you have to pay attention! I'd normally consider that you are an individual, that is experiencing the series in your own way, and I can't judge you if the plot is not being clear to you, but some of the stuff you miss is so clear that I can really only conclude that you are not paying attention when you are watching, it's like you are to focused thinking what nonsense detail are you going to criticize that you skip over the plot points.

>Doug, just watch it normally, stop forcing your way into being a "critic" just a second, just watch the series as it is.
>> No. 112479
>>112476
>>112477
I won't lie, Doug does not have the best head for details. There's a reason he's had like five Nostalgia Critic episodes dedicated to all the times he's gotten stuff wrong.
>> No. 112480
>>112479

I wouldn't even call what he missed in the Book 1 finale 'details' but 'basic major plot points plainly illustrated by the show'.

It's like DSPgaming skipping all the tutorials in MGS2 and MGS3, stumbling through the games like an elephant in an antique store, dying constantly while blaming the CONTROLS and KOJIMA. Look up "this how you DON'T play MGS2/MGS3" on youtube for a facepalm/laughfest
>> No. 112481
>>112480

I have no idea what's up with these later reviews because he was really good about details in the earlier ones. Also lol how does a grown man not know about the moon affecting the tides?
>> No. 112483
File 13720579489.jpg - (11.96KB , 225x225 , images (8).jpg )
112483
>>112481

Merica
>> No. 112485
funny how everyone is just now saying what i said back in >>112428 .

hes not genuinely enjoying the show as he obviously claimed otherwise he would be paying attention and like i said he dismisses all the main plot as stereotypes or kiddie b.s. but goes all fanboy over the actual stereotypes n kiddie b.s. a lot of the "I've never seen that before" shit is text book in asian cinema which is where the whole basis from this show was taken.

again Doug is nothing but a Tool. it was fun in the beginning but now its just heading towards the same epic fail as shamawhatever the fuck his name was.
>> No. 112486
wow just wow this finale thing completely proved every point i made. lol

also no love triangle ever works? i'm guessing this guys never been popular with the ladies love triangles aren't just hollywood... and really? FF 7's didn't work? i disagree.
>> No. 112487
>>112481
Is he homeschooled or something?
>> No. 112489
File 137208688695.png - (268.84KB , 460x480 , contempt Felicity.png )
112489
>>112487
>implying MURRIKAN schools teach that
>> No. 112490
While I agree we could have used another episode to set up the north pole, if he feels this was rushed, he is going to cry blood when he reviews the movie.
>> No. 112494
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39685-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-avatar-state
>> No. 112496
>>112490

Yes, and it will be glorious.

Cool that he seems to like it thus far, though I have a feeling that if he rewatches it again he'll see things he missed the first time.

Like the tide thing.
>> No. 112502
>>112494

Back to original form. He did say he was kinda busy or something during some of the last episodes, so that might be why he was so off on catching plot points for the end of season 1.

This is his side project for fun, so he can do whatever he wants. However, I'd prefer it if he just put off the vlogs when he's really busy until he has time to focus on them. Quality over quantity is more preferable. Him choosing quantity with the NC stuff is what made me drop watching those a few years ago.
>> No. 112508
File 137213897119.gif - (715.62KB , 458x281 , 1372132955782.gif )
112508
>>112494

Much, much better than the last 2 videos. I like how he referenced Iroh's prior redirection of natural lightning back in The Storm.

Watching ATLA the first time around deserves your undivided attention and it showed. I hope he just postpones a new video when things get busy, he'll end up giving the show that much respect through his viewing of Book 2. Especially if he wants to subject himself to making a video review of the god-forsaken TLA.

gif semi-related.
>> No. 112517
>>112485
It's even worse that he constantly refers to the show as a kid show when he can't even figure out half the shit going on. He manages to be both condescending and self-embarrassing at the same time.
>> No. 112518
>>112517
But it is a kids' show. That's why it aired on Nickelodeon.
>> No. 112519
>>112518
Not that anon, but it's gotta be embarrassing when you're using "it's a kid show" to try and justify why you don't understand it's plot points.
>> No. 112520
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39703-the-last-airbender-vlogs-cave-of-two-lovers

He explains a bit of what he means by "filler" in this vlog.
>> No. 112521
For the love of god, how shitty can that video provider be?

I've been waiting this to buffer completely for over 20 minutes.
>> No. 112522
You know, looking at the episode list of book 2 after Avatar day, they really get the ball rolling and it doesn't stop until the season finale.
>> No. 112523
>>112522

Book one sold the show to me.

Book two made me love it.

And I think that book three, despite only getting it's footing around halfway through the season, was a great finale for the show, and wouldn't get so much bad rap if it hadn't started after a goddamned year long hiatus with book 2 finale fueling the hype.
>> No. 112524
>>112523

>being able to watch avatar on youtube.

those were the days.
>> No. 112525
File 137229664872.jpg - (6.59KB , 276x183 , SMIRK.jpg )
112525
>Doug never learned Zhao's name
>still forgets Iroh's frequently
>took multiple eps to get down Sokka and Katara
>Has Azula down pat from the moment she has a named appearance
>> No. 112526
>>112525
So he's a pedophile?
>> No. 112527
>>112526
Nah, if he was a pedophile, delicious brown girl would have probably not been a problem.
>> No. 112528
>>112525
Say what you will about Azula, she leaves an impression.
>> No. 112540
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39717-the-last-airbender-vlogs-return-to-omashu

So Doug apparently never heard them say the name of the city in the episode and he thinks the accent is on the last syllable instead of the second one.
>> No. 112541
>>112540
I never really understood /co/'s hateboner for this guy because I never really bothered to watch him, but I think I do now. He is just really dense.
>> No. 112542
>>112541

I always assumed he was so barely watched any of his videos.

It's nice that he finally got onto a subject we all know very well so we can see just how dense he is though.
>> No. 112543
File 137238495684.jpg - (54.82KB , 446x597 , merika.jpg )
112543
>>112542

There was quite a shitstorm when Doug railed Mako's performance as Splinter in one of the recent TMNT movies. It was one of his final roles and he was suffering from throat cancer, so it clearly effected his performance. Animation and Mako fans were rightfully pissed at him. Pic semi-related.
>> No. 112544
>>112543
I didn't hear his argument and haven't seen the show, but in his defense, if Mako had an illness that was preventing him from doing his job, it's terrible and I feel bad that that happened to him, but that doesn't make his performance any better. There's a reason Michael J. Fox only rarely works anymore, and when he does it's a character where his affliction works, like that OCD doctor in Scrubs, whose OCD took a form that made his Parkinson's-inflicted movements make sense--no matter how much we like a performer and no matter how bad we feel about his affliction, it just doesn't make sense to give someone a job they can't perform anymore.

It's part of that whole "Death of the Author" thing. It's unfair to expect people to research the context of a work before giving their reaction to it for fear someone was in a bad state when they worked on it. They can only react to what's been put in front of them. If that's not up to snuff, it's not up to snuff, even if there's a sympathetic reason why it isn't.
>> No. 112545
It's a weird contrast between although these interesting critical observations he makes and then the blindingly obvious stuff he somehow misses.
>> No. 112547
>>112545
Yeah, I think I'm noticing the same thing. When he goes over something in-depth and takes the time to prepare a scripted critique, I think he provides some nice opinions and insights. But this series is all about him talking about something immediately after he's seen it and it's painfully obvious that he's just not that great at picking up and retaining certain details of the plot.

But I also think it's interesting that people here choose to focus on those errors at the expense of the rest of the analysis. Nobody's talking about the ten minutes of praise for the interesting characters and the show's boldness in introducing its audience to new real-world concepts. They're just talking about the 45 seconds in which he said that he wasn't entirely sure about something that wasn't explicitly stated (but was strongly implied).
>> No. 112550
Everyone interprets stuff differently.
>> No. 112551
>>112543

I remember that, and it was totally blown out of proportion. He had no idea who Mako was or that he died from throat cancer shortly after that role.
>> No. 112552
I get the feeling he's watching the show as background noise while he's washing the dishes or vacuuming or something.
>> No. 112553
>>112540

Ok, finally got around to see the video. Seems like the Omashu pronunciation is a nitpick. He nailed a lot of bullet points of the episode and toward the end he seemed to pick up on the nature of Azula and Ty Lee's relationship. He also picked up instantly that Mai was smitten with Zuko, something the vast majority of Zutarians always miss.
>> No. 112555
>>112553
He's nailed a lot of things Zutarians normally miss. For example, he hasn't mentioned once the fact that Katara is madly in love with the handsome dark prince, and he didn't think the scene where Zuko kidnapped her and tied her to a post had wild sexual overtones.

He is gonna be confused as fuck when he hits season three and the Zuko/Katara fanservice bits start popping up
>> No. 112561
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39732-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-swamp

>>112555
What fanservice? Katara spends most of the third season hating him, they have a reconciliation, and they're allies to the end of the series. The Ember Island Players play with the idea that they were "involved," but he could see that as just another goofy thing the playwrights got wrong.
>> No. 112564
>>112561
That was sarcasm.
>> No. 112565
I'm kinda disappointed he hasn't commented on the sound work at all.
>> No. 112566
>>112561

>last video he complains that Momo does nothing
>spends next video rambling on about the series in general barely touching on the events of the episode you just watched
>episode where Momo and Appa spend a a good part of screen time fending for themselves in the swamp

Fucking terrible.
>> No. 112572
File 137250618967.jpg - (10.11KB , 275x183 , 7537357.jpg )
112572
Soon.
>> No. 112573
>>112566
He'll probably get to it when he covers Tales from BSS.

Boy, that's gonna be a fun episode for him.
>> No. 112574
>>112572
He has already noted Aang's vision, I am awaiting his reaction to the payoff. Come to think of it, if he contemplates the whole plant-bending thing something in Book Three will seem familiar.
>> No. 112575
>>112566
He discussed the fact that this episode felt like it introduced a lot of concepts and was a bit all over the place and mentions that it's hard to say whether or not those concepts will come back later because the show is constantly introducing new concepts. I'm pretty sure he said that as if it was a positive thing, but I'm positive he wasn't complaining about it. The Swamp did introduce a lot of new elements that do come back later (Swampbenders, waterbending plants, Sokka's guilt over Yue, Aang's vision about Toph, Aang and Appa being spiritually connected), so in a sense he's absolutely right in his evaluation of the episode and of series as a whole.

90% of what he says about the show is positive. Why are you watching these videos if you're going to take anything not-positive as a personal insult?
>> No. 112579
>>112561
He's a bit thick, but he's trying to get it.
>> No. 112580
File 13725521248.png - (211.51KB , 387x340 , ummm.png )
112580
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39745-the-last-airbender-vlogs-avatar-day
>Avatar Day
>his second-favorite episode
>> No. 112581
>>112580
It has Kyoshi.

You know, the kind of woman people wanted Korra to be, the lite-yet-dark version.
>> No. 112584
I'm actually glad to see someone who genuinely loves the filler episodes.

They get way too much hate.
>> No. 112585
>>112580

I'm guessing the return of Foamy was a highlight for him
>> No. 112586
>>112580

>yfw he hates "The Blind Bandit"
>> No. 112587
File 137256795294.gif - (468.19KB , 183x200 , punkpumpp.gif )
112587
>>112586

>yfw he hates "The Blind Bandit"
>> No. 112588
>>112585
Foamy was the only negative point he seemed to have regarding the ep

Because it was less magical the second time around and he worries they'll try too hard to force it
>> No. 112589
>>112580

>Avatar Day
>his second-favorite episode

I liked Avatar Day. It gets a lot of flack for being the speed bump in the steamroller that is Book 2, so the rewatchability factor is kinda hurt by it.

By the way, I'm not taking negative opinions as a personal insult. Doug's nagging tendency to miss some obvious things, especially things he was seemingly asking of the show, are the only thing I find grating about this series. That little quip about Momo is a microcosm of this. This Avatar Day video has been one of his best so far.
>> No. 112593
>he really likes the comedy aspect of the show.

the fuel keeps piling up for the movie review.
>> No. 112604
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39765-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-blind-bandit

Psyche! He didn't hate it!
>> No. 112605
>>112604
I wonder what he'll think of Toph's character arc. Will he feel she was underdeveloped?

On a somewhat related note, I found this review of TLA. I liked how he shows even the camera shots are horribly done.
http://chezapocalypse.com/episodes/s3e4-the-last-airbender/
>> No. 112606
Zuko Alone is going to make him lose his shit.
>> No. 112608
>>112605
There will never be enough videos like this to satisfy my hate for the movie and it's why I'll always keep watching them.
>> No. 112609
>>112605
I really appreciate how he went out of his way to break down how Shymalan is by process of elimination, wholly to blame.
>> No. 112610
File 137264681930.gif - (1.55MB , 250x200 , harvey_pump.gif )
112610
>>112604

>Water triiiiibe

I love that Doug is digging some of the gutbusters in the show.

>>112605

>23 minutes of destroying TLA

Pardon me while I make some popcorn.
>> No. 112613
I dunno if you guys knew this, but some of the other reviewers on tgwtg already did a review of TLA. It's pretty good.

http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/ir/yrt/specials/30277-the-last-airbender
>> No. 112619
http://blip.tv/nostalgiacritic/the-last-airbender-vlogs-zuko-alone-6610616

As expected, he hated it and thinks Dante Basco is a terrible voice actor.
>> No. 112620
are you trying to be sarcastic? also i love how hes oblivious to the grandfather threatening zuko's life. (I always assumed the mother killed the grandfather to spare zuko from the grandfather's wishes am i wrong?)
>> No. 112623
>>112613
I'm sure he'll get a ton of e-mails explaining all of the stuff he missed.
>> No. 112624
>>112623
>>112619
Fuck.
>> No. 112632
File 137274399864.jpg - (17.95KB , 400x300 , palpatine (2).jpg )
112632
>He is getting invested in Zuko.

>mfw Crossroads of Destiny
>> No. 112635
>>112619

>admits to recoding several videos/episodes in a single setting
>right in the sweet spot of Book 2
>b-but only because he has a heavy Con schedule coming up, it's not like I like you stupid Avatar!

Doug is officially Tsundere for ATLA I kid, I kid! That long commentary on Dante Basco's VA work was fantastic!
>> No. 112636
>>112635
He's admitted outright to cheating and watching 2-3 eps in a row multiple times already besides this one

he's hooked
>> No. 112637
>>112632
I wonder if he'll be one of those fans who think that Zuko's 'betrayal' in Crossroads was completely OOC and made no sense.
>> No. 112640
he also seems to have a bad habit of missing obvious things when he marathons. maybe he should stick to one at a time?
>> No. 112641
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39781-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-chase
>> No. 112643
>>112641
Think he hit all the nails on the head.
>> No. 112645
>>112641
The Chase is probably one of my favorite episode of the series and Doug really gets why, I think. There is a simplicity in the concept that leads to so much chaos within the Gaang and really defines Toph's character more than any of her earlier episodes, even the Blind Bandit.

Also this episode has arguably the best fight in the series and really cemented Azula as one of my favorite characters.
>> No. 112646
File 137282950220.png - (366.54KB , 720x480 , diabeetus.png )
112646
>>112645

The ending scene, like Doug said, is also goddamn perfect. On my first viewing when Aang is confronting Azula with those circles under his eyes I was all "REALLY? A FIGHT NOW? COME ON AND LET THE KID FUCKING SLEEP ALREADY!" And the behavior of the rest of the Gaang as they joined the fight with a "fuck this noise" attitude and their reward at the end of the ordeal was LET US SLEEP GODDAMMIT.

their little exhausted dogpile is adorable
>> No. 112705
Didn't watch it. Does he mention that "The Chase" is probably inspired by the Battlestar Galactica episode "33" AKA the most shit yourself intense hour in television of all time?
>> No. 112706
>>112705
You seriously think that's where they got their inspiration from? Depriving your enemy of sleep is not an uncommon tactic, in fact it's one of the most tried and true ones.
>> No. 112708
I wonder if he'll watch the next few back to back, since they aired together
>> No. 112711
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39795-the-last-airbender-vlogs-bitter-work
>> No. 112731
>4 minutes long

You're getting lazy.
>> No. 112732
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39811-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-library

>Aaaaappaaa! Nooooooo! Come baaaack Aaaappa! Aaaaaa!
>> No. 112733
>>112731
Convention seasons coming up.

Still disappointing.
>> No. 112735
>>112732

I know it's a holiday weekend, but I think Toph deserves at least a quick mention for her role in the episode if he's in a rush to record these. The conflict she faced was a critical part of the climax. Con season, fine, off he goes. Rather unfortunate it coincided with the beginning of this character-heavy arc.
>> No. 112737
There's a reason these are called vlogs and not reviews guys.
>> No. 112741
yeah...? no. he said he would REVIEW this show. so much for that excuse lol
>> No. 112784
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39840-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-desert

Seven minutes, twenty-one seconds. Happy?
>> No. 112792
Weird.

I was almost sure he was going to comment on Sokka being high.
>> No. 112830
File 137324831582.png - (150.16KB , 360x300 , Screen Shot 2013-07-07 at 9_49_27 PM.png )
112830
An image can say over 9,000 words.
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39851-the-last-airbender-vlogs-serpents-pass
>> No. 112832
Crap, the finale is not numbered in parts.

Someone has to tell him to watch it in one sitting.
>> No. 112835
>>112832
Do it, friend.
>> No. 112845
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39862-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-drill

A lot of praise, but some criticism as well. Thoughts?
>> No. 112846
>>112845

Finally some credit to the Track Team.
>> No. 112847
>>112845

Well, the drill does come back as the final proof to the Earth King, not sure if that will be enough.
>> No. 112859
i think he needs to learn what filler is and stop throwing it on every ep he can personally do without. fucking tool...
>> No. 112860
>>112859
He praises the episode in almost every way, but because he called it "filler" he's an idiot? Seems like you're just looking for things about which to be angry with him.
>> No. 112861
I honestly prefer this guy's day to day videos. He seems way more genuine and funny than his other videos. It's nice to hear someone praise avatar for its cinematography.

>>112859
I think you need to learn what a tool is.
This is his first viewing and he's doing so one episode at a time. God knows how many people probably also thought this. And he's not an anime fan, to him "filler" isn't codeword for throw away episode, more like world building and stuff.
>> No. 112870
File 137339987755.gif - (533.19KB , 500x314 , 1370030255367.gif )
112870
>city of wall and secrets is next.
>> No. 112871
File 137341870180.png - (208.33KB , 640x360 , rf Critic looks death in the face.png )
112871
>>112870
Here you go, Shinji
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39871-the-last-airbender-vlogs-city-of-walls-and-secrets#josc793926
>> No. 112872
So the brother wants to chime in "Tales of Ba-sing-se".

I wonder what is he going to say.
>> No. 112874
>>112872
I think they're both going to be blown away.

Though I hope they lay off of the Mako backlash joke they did in the during the Critics earlier shows.
>> No. 112896
>>112871

>dramatic shift in tone once the Gaang enters Ba Sing Se
>"Well I've seen this sort of commentary before"

*WHOOOSH*
>> No. 112897
>>112896
I don't get it. What exactly went over his head? How does the tonal shift (which I don't think was that dramatic) relate to him observing that this 1984-esque society isn't an original idea?
>> No. 112906
Real quick, can we all agree to not get angry if Doug calls "Tales of Ba Sing Se" filler?
>> No. 112908
>>112906
I learned to not get angry after he bashed Rover Dangerfield.
>> No. 112909
>>112908
Why would that not make you mad?!
>> No. 112910
>>112908
>No respect
>> No. 112911
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39880-the-last-airbender-vlogs-tales-of-ba-sing-se

Triple the length of his standard vlogs.
>> No. 112912
File 137350037444.png - (214.19KB , 720x480 , ep59-596.png )
112912
>>112911

I'd argue Zuko's reunion in the book 3 finale is just as powerful as Iroh's tale.
>> No. 112925
>>112911

I loved this one. My only gripe is Rob using TLA's pronunciations for Sokka and Iroh.

>Soh-ka
>Eeroh

absolutelydisgusting.jpg
>> No. 112930
File 13735177309.jpg - (48.18KB , 800x533 , disgust.jpg )
112930
Idiot Alert on page 3 of the comments:

>Username: DeDreamer

>My brother and I hated this episode on our first view, still hate it on the re-watch.

>The stories are completely random and inane doing nothing to develop character. Toph's "I don't care what I look like" moral is meaningless because she has never cared what she looks like and will continue not to care into the future. What would have been a more meaningful point maybe would have been a discussion about her inability to share in something that is such a big part of her friends' lives but they didn't have time for that so they went with a cheap afternoon special moral. Aang and Sokka's "tales" are outright obnoxious enough to be painful to sit through for even 2 minutes. Zuko's is just bland and we never get to see him interact with that character again. It's like the plot of a million kiddie cartoons, it's not the least bit illuminating.

>Iroh's short is sad. But if it was really so special why not make an entire episode around Iroh and dedicate that to Mako? Or better yet, why not have made Iroh's journey through the city the connecting thread. One scene does not make an episode. So many other things you've nitpicked Rob and yet you'll overlook everything that's wrong with this episode for one decent scene?

>This episode is just really, horribly written and is the only episode I will never watch again after this viewing. It's just painfully dull, worse than any other filler episode Two Lovers and Painted Lady included.
>> No. 112955
>>112930
To be honest, I have to agree with that commentator to an extent. Toph/Katara's, Sokka's and Aang's tales I all found rather dull, how much I enjoy Zuko's varied according to my mood. Iroh's and Momo's are the only ones I can say I 'enjoy' every time.

On the whole, I never found Tales of Ba Sing Se that entertaining. On the Gaang's side, at least, I think it would have worked much better as one interwoven narrative.
>> No. 112964
>>112930
So, you are angry because someone dislikes what you like?
>> No. 112965
>>112955
Not liking Sokka's poetry slam is a clear sign that you are insane. You should see a doctor.
>> No. 112974
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39895-the-last-airbender-vlogs-appas-lost-days

Kinda annoyed that they ignored the Suki's group getting captured, but I guess they aren't the main focus.
>> No. 112984
>>112974
We never see the Warriors getting captured, we just see them losing as Appa flies away. We don't find out what happens to them until Azula brings it up in "Day of Black Sun."
>> No. 112985
>>112984
It's not hard to make a guess after seeing Azula and co. in the Kyoshi get-up when they appear later on.

There were some that even thought Azula had killed Suki.
>> No. 112994
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39928-the-last-airbender-vlogs-lake-laogai
>> No. 113000
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39942-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-earth-king
>> No. 113001
>>113000

>he is going to watch the finale split.

god damn it
>> No. 113003
http://blip.tv/nostalgiacritic/the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-guru-6614892

Oh Doug, you crazy bastard.
>> No. 113005
>>113003
Tomorrow is going to be great.
>> No. 113009
I can't be the only one who finds Rob really annoying.
>> No. 113011
>>113005
Turns out I overestimated it.
>> No. 113015
>>113009

>Rob has seen the whole series
>still doesn't know Azula and Zuko's ages in relation to each other

He's a mixed bag and a bad influence on Doug's reviews
>> No. 113016
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39965-the-last-airbender-vlogs-crossroads-of-destiny
>> No. 113018
>>113009
I have to agree. I've been playing catch-up with these reviews so I can post in this thread again, and I was really looking forward to this one, but he damn near ruined it all.

>Constantly interrupts Doug to the point of talking over him and taking over most of the review
>Hinting too much about Season 3 stuff
>Draws out the argument over whether Zuko's attempted "metamorphosis" was genuine
>Compares the finale too hard to Star Wars at the end

DUDE, SHUT UP ALREADY. I WANT TO THROTTLE Y--

>"Soak-ah"

Oh, I get it now. He's an M. Night plant.
>> No. 113021
>>113018
I stopped watching midway through his second rant. At that point he was arguing for the sake of arguing. Doug conceded that Rob had a point, but that his own opinions were simply how he read it and what irked him personally. They were pretty much agreeing with each other but Rob just kept arguing, and it was painful to watch.
>> No. 113022
with his brother dropping major spoiler bits it might be a good thing doug is dense sometimes.
>> No. 113027
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39981-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-awakening

>>113022
Which "major spoilers?" I heard allusions to Aang's personal struggles, but no specifics were really given.
>> No. 113029
>>113027

>that ending

I fucking lol'd
>> No. 113070
So the brothers back.
>> No. 113078
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39995-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-headband

Get ready for more Rob!
>> No. 113080
>>113070
he wasn't that distracting this time. heck, some of the parallels he brought up were rather interesting. I think he's just a little obnoxious when he eggs on about star wars or other pop culture things.
also, it is nice to see brothers doing stuff together.
>> No. 113109
The parallels he brought up were pretty accurate, though he could have possibly have said that he meant pre-Communist China when talking about the Earth Kingdom... though the police state aspect does share some simularities. Y'know, nevermind.

The Imperial Japan/Fire Nation thing was pretty accurate though, more so than just the Honour and navy thing. The level of indoctrination was so high there there were still people who didn't want Japan to surrender even after the nukes were dropped.

Hell, there was even an attempted military coup to oust the current government and install the Emperor was a puppet leader so one group of generals could cheap fighting. Even if the already starving population would have to fight the advancing American and Soviet armies armed only with the rocks they were able to scavenge in the midst of their radioactive wasteland.

People not wanting to surrender even when a more moderate government (well, moderate is the wrong work in the case of Japan, COMPLIANT would be a better one) has been established has been shown numerous times in the Avatarverse in the post-War comics as well.

Even though people like Mai's dad have literally no chance of going back to the Old Days due to both international pressure and the fact that there's a walking WMD out there with an investment in them not coming back, it doesn't stop them from grasping at the hope that it's all just a phase.
>> No. 113124
Rob wont shut up.
>> No. 113163
File 137432708426.png - (367.89KB , 580x610 , Screen Shot 2013-07-20 at 9_28_46 AM.png )
113163
A lucky pause.
>> No. 113170
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40021-the-last-airbender-vlogs-sokkas-master

I think his criticisms of Robert Patrick's performance pretty much reflect my own. Great character, weak voice acting.
>> No. 113175
>next up is "The Beach"

I wonder how is he going to take it
>> No. 113176
>>113170
I miss rob...
>> No. 113177
>>113175

Considering how much glee he gets from Azula, he'll almost assuredly love the parts with her. As for the rest of the breakfast club, being the 80's nostalgia guy who likes villains episodes but has trouble with filler (whatever that means in his mind) he's either going to love it or hate it.

>>113176

How does it feel to truly be the loneliest person on the planet?
>> No. 113189
Speaking of Sokka's Master...
YTP: Sokka Blows up the Weapon Shopyoutube thumb
>> No. 113205
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40031-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-beach

Yeah, he liked it.
>> No. 113208
>>113205
saw that coming. Though it was filler, Doug manages to make me appreciate theses episodes in a different light. kudos to his film degree.

>>113177
>How does it feel to truly be the loneliest person on the planet?

how does it feel to hate fun?
>> No. 113212
>>113208

If your definition of fun is having Rob, someone who has seen the entire show, constantly interrupt with his own opinions and sometimes outright spoil things for Doug - when a large part of the entertainment of these vlogs stems from watching the initial reactions of someone who has never seen the entire show and doesn't know what's coming, then I guess I feel pretty damn good hating fun.

But seriously, even when he could be useful, like debating different interruptions of themes with Doug, he just doesn't know when to stop. It gets to the point where he keeps arguing with Doug even though Doug's not really disagreeing with him.

Not trying to shit on you specifically for liking Rob, but for me he honestly has been an overall detriment.

Plus, when Rob and Doug work on writing the movie review together, Rob is most likely going to have them leave out any criticisms about how M Night got all the names wrong, since it seems like he's totally on board with M Night's reasoning about "pronouncing them the proper way."
>> No. 113232
>>113212
oh, no. yeah, I was just joking. If anything I just love how people complain about rob.
>> No. 113235
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40038-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-avatar-and-the-firelord
>> No. 113238
Is there a reason why I should care about NostalgiaCritic or anything he does?
>> No. 113239
>>113238

Not if you don't want to, but why even come onto the thread and ask if you know you don't?
>> No. 113248
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40063-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-runaway

I think Doug pretty much nailed why I like this episode so much: great jokes and great heart.
>> No. 113258
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40071-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-puppetmaster
>> No. 113259
Well, being slightly computer literate has it's perks.

Doug pre-recorded a bunch of videos on the 19th, and I managed to dig up his reviews up to the western air temple.

He's loving it.
>> No. 113262
wow Doug you managed to say the same fucking thing over n over for damn near 15 minutes. clearly you know your shit. this guy is cearial talented right here.
>> No. 113267
File 137481604819.gif - (2.46MB , 360x270 , ijsp4HfVgyzV4.gif )
113267
>>113258

>Bloodbending is the act of forcefully stripping a person of control of their own limbs and imposing your will on them
>Doug doesn't understand why this is wrong
>> No. 113273
>>113267
He gets that it's wrong, but just doesn't agree that it's as wrong as they make it out to be. The show portrays blood bending as some kind of dark art or forbidden technique, like just using it once destroys part of your soul, but he thinks that there could be good reasons to blood bend, like how Katara uses it to save Aang and Sokka.
>> No. 113275
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40085-the-last-airbender-vlogs-nightmares-and-daydreams
>> No. 113286
File 137494425957.jpg - (336.61KB , 800x600 , day-of-black-sun.jpg )
113286
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40095-the-last-airbender-the-day-of-black-sun-1-a-2
>> No. 113290
>>113286
well aside from that lil bit of name frustration, he actually managed to stay on point for this one.
>> No. 113302
Next up is the episode that made me like Firebending above all else.
>> No. 113303
File 137513394836.jpg - (38.21KB , 750x600 , Zukaang-avatar-the-last-airbender-10924108-750-600.jpg )
113303
>>113302

>Next up is the episode that made me like Zukaang above all else.
>> No. 113304
>>113302
It still makes me wonder why stopping a genocide apparently wasn't enough of a motivation for Zuko's firebending, though.
>> No. 113305
File 13751423099.png - (295.23KB , 656x834 , Screen Shot 2013-07-25 at 3_49_26 PM.png )
113305
>>113303
lel

GENTLEMEN AND GENTLELADIES... BEHOLD!
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40117-last-airbender-vlog-the-dragonbending-masters
>> No. 113306
>>113305

I'm beginning to think he has some form of dyslexia
>> No. 113307
File 137514399533.png - (42.26KB , 144x193 , Nostalgia Critic will eat you after you go asleep.png )
113307
>>113306
Well well, aren't we grumpy today?
>> No. 113308
>>113307

Yeah... that came out harsher than intended.

Good to see he is really enjoying the show.

The finale is going to knock his socks off.
>> No. 113309
wow you guys totally skipped one....

http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40104-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-western-air-temple
>> No. 113310
>>113306
>I'm beginning to think he has some form of dyslexia

I think he does. He comments on being "dyslexic as hell" in the audio commentary for his The Care Bears Movie review while asking his brother why he didn't catch that he misspelled the word penguin, and that's only one instance out of dozens where he's misspelled a word.
>> No. 113311
File 137526177794.jpg - (43.16KB , 517x369 , seriouslyrobstoptalking.jpg )
113311
>Catching up again
>More Rob
>WHY.jpg
>Still saying "EEroh" and "Mayko" and "Soak-uh"

HOW CAN YOU WATCH THE ENTIRE SERIES AND STILL NOT GET THIS RIGHT?!

>Watching "The Painted Lady" vlog
>Rob gives away spoilers for DoBS

GOD FUCKING DAMMIT.

>Doug tries to ask him about how to pronounce Sokka (instead of um, listening to what they say in the show)
>Rob uses the "It's fantasy, who cares?" excuse for continuing to say SOAK-UH, or thinks it might be Japanese
>Says "Suki" is Japanese for moon, when that's "TSUKI"

AAAAAGGGGGGH.

Someone please e-mail Doug or something. This is getting fucking painful. I was joking about Rob being an M. Night plant before, but now I fear that if he keeps confusing Doug, he'll give him reasons to make excuses for some of the shit in the TLA movie.
>> No. 113312
>>113311
The mispronounced names are the least of the problems with that movie. Even if they give them a pass on that, there's still a hundred other reasons to nail the movie to the wall.
>> No. 113313
>>113312

Why are you stanning so hard for Doug and defending all of his fuckups in this thread?
>> No. 113314
>>113313
Are you seriously implying the mispronounced names were the biggest problem in the movie? Cause that's just skewed priorities.
>> No. 113315
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/nostalgia-critic/40137

Oh doug, you have no idea...
>> No. 113316
>>113315
Don't know what he's talking about with Mai but everything else was great.
>> No. 113317
File 137531310738.gif - (471.30KB , 247x166 , ohyes.gif )
113317
>>113313
I like the guy and I want to provide some angle of defense for all the criticisms that get leveled against him.

>>113315
>"I'd like to see [Azula] fall apart."

Oh boy.
>> No. 113318
File 13753387543.jpg - (7.23KB , 259x194 , cornette.jpg )
113318
>>113315

>He got Mai and Ty Lee's names right
>nailing Azula's breakdown at the first sign being shown in this episode

That wasn't even on the tip of my brain until the Southern Raiders where she outright said "ZUKO, YOU'RE FUKKEN DEAD!"
>> No. 113322
>>113318

Southern Raiders confirmed it for me, but I suspected right from the ending of Boiling Rock like Doug. It was the first time Azula's voiced any real emotion over something not going her way.

When she was cornered in The Chase, or tried to convince Zuko to join her in the caves under Ba Sing Se, or wasn't sure if Zuko thought Aang might still be alive...those were all situations that COULD have ended bad for her, but at the same time, she always sounded like she was still in control or at least had a plan to get control back. Like, even though those weren't ideal scenarios, they were ultimately still scenarios that she had dissected beforehand as possibilities and prepared for if necessary.

But with Mai and Ty Lee's betrayal, from the surprise and emotion in her voice, you could just tell that she never even came close to fathoming that they would do that to her. And as such, it completely shattered the core foundation of her entire world view - there was something inside of her sphere of influence that could still go wrong that she couldn't plan for and handle accordingly. She was not perfect.

And if that wasn't enough, the thing that went wrong was that the only two people she considered "friends," or at the very least considered most loyal, were in fact not - which was probably the WORST possible thing to happen to Miss "My own mother thought I was a monster."

But yeah, the opening to Southern Raiders definitely made it clear that the events of the previous episode had a profound and lasting effect of her.
>> No. 113324
I am curious as to how the eventual Nostalgia Critic review of the film will go, now that Doug has reaffirmed that he considers things like the characterisation, voice acting, art direction etc. are so good in the show itself...

Getting invested in the show before reviewing the movie should make it particularly scathing, or will just come across as obnoxious to people who haven't been watching the vlogs or the show itself. We'll see.
>> No. 113325
>he is reviewing the finale in four episodes.

god damn it.
>> No. 113326
>>113325
Don't the episodes themselves say "Part One/Two/Three/Four"? Why wouldn't he watch them together?
>> No. 113327
>>113326

he is watching them together, but is stopping to review each episode individually.
>> No. 113328
In other news, he loved the Southern Raiders, but thought the Ember Island Players was just ok.
>> No. 113329
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40148-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-southern-raiders

http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40158-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-ember-island-players
>> No. 113330
File 137549134284.jpg - (51.04KB , 973x171 , fsd.jpg )
113330
>>113327

And he pre-uploaded only half the finale.

What a douche, doesn't he know getting these early is tiresome as hell?
>> No. 113336
>>113328

Not too surprising. EIP was written for the fans. To really find it funny, you really had to be online for all the speculation, shipping wars, and general fan in-jokes at the time.
>> No. 113337
>>113336
It also sounds like people were way over-hyping it for him as well. Which is a sure way to ruin anything.
>> No. 113338
again I blame rob...........
>> No. 113339
>>113336

i wasn't and i still loved it. the only thing i didn't really get was the great divide gag, because i wasn't aware of the community's consensus on it as the worst episode.

what it comes down to is people told him too much about the episode and ended up influencing his expectations and ultimate opinion of it. consider my jimmies mega-rustled.

also as a fan whose favourite characters are toph and zuko and love any interaction between the two, him saying that their scene was unnecessary is personally upsetting.

on a similar note, him not getting the actor toph gag is just silliness. might it have been funnier if she was offended? maybe, but that's not the point. it's pure character-driven comedy. actor toph is basically her own self-image.
>> No. 113341
>>113329

>fandom at odds on Southern Raiders

>Doug fucking lves it

>fandom collectively love Ember Island Player

>Doug is meh about it

Whatcha gonna do? He's watching these episodes as an outsider with no sense of time of happenings within the fandom as the show aired. My jimmies were mildly jostled at the confusion of Zuko and Toph's interaction. That's it.
>> No. 113342
There are instances where people argue that seasons of certain television shows benefit immensely from watching the episodes all at once on DVD, but if there was ever an instance where for just a single episode of a show the opposite effect was true, where watching it on DVD detracted from it, EIP might be it.

Avatar premiered in early 05, and ended in the summer of 08, so there were people watching who first saw the show after their first few months into high school and then watched the finale a month after graduating. That's a long time to ask kids, even slightly older kids, to remember all the important details from a long, overarching television show, especially when most kids shows are written to be episodic.

The episode was meant to remind everyone of the grand adventure that had taken place and calm everyone down before the giant finale, while also being written as love letter and thank you to long time, hardcore fans.

Since Doug has been watching these episodes back to back over the course of months, rather than spread out over years, and he hasn't been involved in the fandom - he was never going to get the same reaction out of the episode as a lot of people did.

That's not to say he couldn't enjoy it, or never had a chance at loving it - because the episode was certainly written where even causal or recent fans of the show can get a lot from it, but there's a subtext there that just wasn't meant for him. There was just that one finale acknowledgement - yes, the creators of the show really do understand how deep a connection their show has made with so many people, and now that it's about to end they really are thankful for the support and love over the years.
>> No. 113343
>>113342
Really, this is true of all Recap Episodes to a certain extent. EIP was a great way to do a recap episode, and avoided most of the cheap shortcuts most recap episodes go through where they just make a clip show, but it's still a recap episode. Recap episodes serve no purpose for someone who's watching the show in a compressed manner, really.

So yeah, you're right. It's never going to work as well for a person who's first experience of the show is on DVD. Recap episodes are for the week-to-weekers.
>> No. 113345
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40172
>> No. 113346
>>113345
He loses points for using the phrase "Geek Peeps."
>> No. 113355
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40187-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-old-masters
>> No. 113356
>>113355

>ALL THESE EMOTIONS ;_;
>> No. 113382
>rob is back

god damn it.
>> No. 113383
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40206-the-last-airbender-vlogs-into-the-inferno

>>113382
Problem?
>> No. 113387
>lol awwww poor wobbies all buthurt.

LMFAO fucking tool...
>> No. 113389
I don't care for his brother joining in, but he didn't take away from it.
>> No. 113390
File 137593983610.gif - (1.75MB , 200x293 , ibtHTRoLAVA8PA.gif )
113390
>>113383

>Rob is back
>> No. 113391
File 137594111860.gif - (1.00MB , 200x150 , 1375919391871.gif )
113391
>Azula's fire only turned blue during her mental breakdown

Jesus fucking christ, guys.
>> No. 113392
>>113391

To be fair, her fire was not always blue.
>> No. 113393
File 137594249142.png - (490.32KB , 720x480 , ep23-976.png )
113393
>>113392

Her firebending was blue from the very first instance of her actually bending fire onscreen (pictured is a screencap from Return to Omashu, in The Avatar State she was only shown bending lightning). Her name is AZULa for crying out loud. It's not a big secret.
>> No. 113398
File 137594741439.jpg - (47.98KB , 300x262 , aspect ratio.jpg )
113398
>>113393
I am still surprised no one fixed that wrong aspect ratio on those old ass screencaps.

For NTSC anamorphic fullscreen it needs to be 540x720.
>> No. 113399
>>113389
that's because he finely stopped cutting doug off. well mostly. he kinda reverted back to well rob there towards the end.

if you don't like the comments about you wobbie don't be such a fucking tool. (doug is also a tool but not cause hes fighting for the spotlight but because he nitpicks for 6 - 10 mins in every fucking review... but its not important just a lil nitpick that took up half the time)

and god dammit why does rob even have to be their for the important ones. but that's just me nitpicking...
>> No. 113400
>>113392

no dude azula has never once bent normal fire in the entire series (im pretty sure she never actually bent in the flashbacks) its always been blue/lightning. its meant to be a sign of her over acheiving personality i guess cause its supposed to be the top tier fire bending at least from what i understood.
>> No. 113401
File 137596989433.jpg - (45.59KB , 720x480 , 414.jpg )
113401
>>113400
>no dude azula has never once bent normal fire in the entire series (im pretty sure she never actually bent in the flashbacks)

She was shown bending regular fire at least three times in Zuko Alone. Once when she burnt the doll Iroh gave her, again when she shot the apple off Mai's head, and most clearly during her demonstration for Azulon.
>> No. 113402
File 137597063766.gif - (14.42KB , 250x459 , techcolour-temp-chart.gif )
113402
>>113383

>Blue flame means its colder, and probably weaker!

...God dammit did you guys not have High School science?
>> No. 113405
There is no way they don't know that Azula's fire has always been blue, or at the very least that it was blue long before now. I assumed that, when they talked about the red fire changing to blue, they meant inside the Fire Nation throne room.
>> No. 113412
>>113402

Blue fire isn't necessarily always hotter than orange fire, but it's definitely cleaner and more efficient. Between this and Doug not understanding how the moon affects the tide, I'm really wondering about his science education.
>> No. 113413
>>113412


>Between this and Doug not understanding how the moon affects the tide,

wait, wat?
>> No. 113414
>>113400
> its meant to be a sign of her over acheiving personality
The understanding I got from Iroh's description was that it was more a sign of Azula's nature--fire is powered by emotion and passion, and blue fire and/or lightning came from, more or less, "cold blooded fury." That is to say, it was Azula's anger and/or passion, but tempered by discipline that is uncommon among powerful firebenders.

But while I could've sworn that was something Iroh had said earlier in the series, the finale sort of made it difficult for me to reconcile that--if it were true, Azula's fire should've turned red in the finale, once she lost control of her emotions and all.

So yeah, I don't know. Maybe it's just raw power, and nothing to do with technique.
>> No. 113415
>>113414
Pretty sure that the "cold blooded firebending" was only supposed to represent lightning bending, and that it was called such because it wasn't derived from emotions at all, but rather single minded focus on a goal. Azula, presumably, could only manage to lightning bend in the finale because killing (or mentally wrecking) Zuko was the only thing she could actually fully commit to.

As for the blue fire, I don't think it was ever explained in universe as to why it burned a different colour. Given how the fire she creates in Zuko Alone to surround Aang with quickly turns orange/red, it seems to be something she has to maintain, so it's entirely possible that any firebender could possibly change the hue of their flames, but the difficulty in doing so means that most only learn it as a party trick (IIRC, I think the performer at the festival in The Deserter had differently coloured flames). Assuming such to be the case, it's likely that Azula adopted the use of differently coloured fire in order to show off her superiority, and over time, it simply became second nature and essentially her 'default' colour.
>> No. 113416
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40220-the-last-airbender-vlogs-avatar-aang

Well, it's been fun.
>> No. 113417
>>113416

>He is going to watch legend of Korra.

>He hates contrived romance triangles.

This should be fun.
>> No. 113418
wow rob actually gets points for this one ok it was worth it to watch em all but they are both still tools just a lil less tooly. for now. their skits are still unfunny though.
>> No. 113422
>And then the lights, and the BOOM and then Ozai BOOMED and then Aang! The colors man. THE COLORS!
Ok that opening was funny.
Glad that Doug is going to review Korra too, and possible do vlogs during book 2 as they come out. Overall I enjoyed his vlogs. I wish he could have gotten the names earlier on but oh well.
>> No. 113423
OH GOD! I just remembered that this whole thing was a build up to him watching the live action movie. HE'S GOING TO WATCH THE LIVE ACTION MOVIE! That is a thing that is going to happen.

After seeing his overwhelmingly positive reaction to the series, there's a good possibility that the movie review may end up being nothing more than several minutes of him swinging from a noose.
>> No. 113424
I have to admit I'm not really a fan of Doug Walker's work and writing and all that, but from just watching him be himself and out of character, he seems like an alright guy. He seems like he's excitable, passionate and a person who likes to have fun, so getting the chance to watch the first reactions of someone like that as they pour so much time and energy toward a show I myself love so much really has been great.

And even his brother, who really was grating at times, also seems to have an immensely high level of respect for the show, which I can respect in return.

So yeah, like I said, even though I'm not a big fan of most of his actual writing and production, I'm actually excited to see what he thinks of the movie. Or as excited as someone can be to watch another human being submit themselves to the epitome of bastardization that is TLA.

I honestly think it'd be better if he just reviewed the movie in the style of the vlogs by watching it and then immediately sitting in front of a camera for two hours and letting his anger and disappointment flow, but since it sounds like he's going to do it in a style more akin to his normal reviews, I can only he doesn't ham it up as much as he normally does in what I've seen of his work. If he really does love Avatar as much as he says he does, then he won't have force anything for the sake of comedy. Whatever raw emotions he really does feel will be exactly perfect.
>> No. 113427
>>113424
I was hoping for something along the lines of him having his brother set the recorder to show his face and jazz hands as the movie progresses.

"No matter what happens, keep this footage rolling."
>> No. 113429
-Rob not hammering on Lionturtle deus ex machina like /co/ tends to
-actually says it makes some sense according to the worldbuilding, especially Aang's steadfastness to not kill Ozai despite everyone telling him to


Now that ATLA is wrapped up Rob's presence is welcome now that he's not spoiling shit and it's refreshing.

>ATLA is at the top of Rob and Doug's top shows list

>THE COLORS

>Doug is going to begin work on TLA in a few days
Undertaker Dead Man Walking Entrance Videoyoutube thumb

RIP in peace Doug
>> No. 113458
The breakdown they did on the ladies nicely contrasts the complaints people are handing Doug over the SM review.
>> No. 113461
>>113417
Will he become a member of team Asami? Hell I still root for her because the others are such cardboard and I like her personality with Korra.
>> No. 113467
>>113458
What happened?
>> No. 113502
File 137653013298.jpg - (87.84KB , 955x535 , sdsad.jpg )
113502
>First Korra review is up.

And

Here

We

Go.
>> No. 113535
when's he going to review that shitfest already?
>i want to laugh at his disappointment.
>> No. 113537
File 137660383575.png - (12.14KB , 436x435 , 1308071583926.png )
113537
>>113535
>FireLo
>> No. 113538
am not...

>i was referring to the last failbender.
>> No. 113539
>>113538
Oh. I thought you were talking about Korra because of the post right above yours.
>> No. 113540
fuck nah i love korra. xD my bad.
>> No. 113575
is he freaking out that Korra seems to lean toward older age group than the last one?
>> No. 113577
Not really, he says that he noticed how its slanted towards older viewers (while Avatar was a family show slanted towards kids) but he didn't really have any objection to it.

Overall he seemed to like the first episode and how he didn't know how it was going to progress, as from the start it didn't have a set goal like Airbender did. Not "We must go to the North Pole to learn waterbending to stop he war!" type stakes yet.

Rob at least seems to be aware of the... issues surrounding the production, so when observations start about the first season seeming rushed start, Doug should at least have someone on hand to tell him why.
>> No. 113582
File 137675045987.gif - (862.01KB , 500x518 , be-the-leaf.gif )
113582
http://blip.tv/nostalgiacritic/legend-of-korra-vlogs-a-leaf-in-the-wind-6629849
>> No. 113584
>>113577
Yea I tend to watch the now "first season" with the knowledge that Nick decided to spin this one shot "slice of another Avatar life" series into a full series and that led to some production scrabble.
>> No. 113587
File 137677566491.png - (169.60KB , 348x419 , link.png )
113587
>>113582

Those are actually some pretty good points...
>> No. 113588
>>113577
Care to share your info?
>> No. 113589
>>113577
>>113584
>>113588
I'm pretty sure what's being referred to is how Korra Season 1 was only granted for 12 episodes with no confirmation on the other seasons until ratings came in. This was due to how poorly the live action movie flopped, Nick was afraid audiences would be soured by the franchise.

However, while this situation was forced on Bryan and Mike, at the same time they said they were eager to do a self-contained and shorter story in several interviews. And honestly, even if they did want more episodes, the fact remains is that they are writers and it's their job to cope with such constraints as all other writers do. Many other shows with less episodes have no issues with pacing, so saying they "only had 12 episodes" is frankly no excuse.
>> No. 113590
>>113589
>with no confirmation on the other seasons until ratings came in.
Actually they knew before even finishing book 1 there'd be a book 2. Book 1 was actually supposed to air in 2011 but got pushed back because of nick ordering book 2.
>> No. 113591
>>113590

That could explain the bloat in book 1.

Introducing things that wouldn't be fully developed in the first season because they knew they had a new season coming.
>> No. 113592
>>113590
But not before getting a lot of work done on Book 1. When they started work on Book 1, it was under the assumption it would be a short miniseries. They got expanded to 13 episodes about halfway through, and then a few months later came the news that they'd be getting additional seasons. They almost certainly already had a few episodes under their belts before getting either piece of news.
>> No. 113593
File 137679758495.png - (107.06KB , 396x381 , Amon-amon-30649081-396-381.png )
113593
http://blip.tv/nostalgiacritic/legend-of-korra-vlogs-the-revelation-6629929
>> No. 113595
>>113592
which is why things start to get wobbly in now having to expand Korra development like she needing more training as the Avatar in the Spirit and then attempting to set up relationships a bit more than Avatar did early I mean Aang was crushing on Katara but it was never really brought out till much later in the seasons that the affection was mutual and that it was more than just a crush.
>> No. 113596
>>113595
Are you serious? First of all, you're making some huge assumptions as to their situation. Almost straight up fabrication at this point. And secondly, it doesn't even matter. In the end, they wrote some poorly paced episodes. They made the end decision to include what they decided to include. This isn't the same sort of bullshit with Nick execs saying "we think there should be dialogue in this silent scene", this is the matter of stuffing too much in and poor pacing. Bryan and Mike as the only writers for the show are the only ones who can be responsible for that.
>> No. 113598
>>113596
You are extraordinarily naive as to how making television works. But I understand why that is--you were dissatisfied with the finished product, and having someone to blame makes things simpler to process than having to accept that sometimes things are complicated.
>> No. 113602
File 137686884943.jpg - (31.41KB , 636x359 , Spirit of Competition.jpg )
113602
As expected, he really didn't like "The Spirit of Competition"
>> No. 113603
>>113602

All that proves is that Doug has shit taste
>> No. 113604
And its aaaaaall downhill from here
>> No. 113606
>>113604

he'll probably like the next three episodes.
>> No. 113610
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40332-the-legend-of-korra-vlogs-spirit-of-competition

Oh yeah, it's bad.
>> No. 113611
File 137695743686.jpg - (56.34KB , 494x494 , 1370851153250.jpg )
113611
>tfw Spirit of Competition is one of your favorite episodes.
>> No. 113624
I'm glad that he's still sticking with it and not letting the bad love triangle put him off too much, but unfortunately for him, it's not over yet. I'm also a little surprised the blatant cheating by the Wolfbats didn't annoy him as much as it did me. I mean really, everyone in the audience was just that accepting of it? Rather than cheating back or continuing to play while just letting those flagrant fouls slide, I feel like the Fire Ferrets could have halted the game without giving it up, maybe tried to get the refs called out or something. It was just bad storytelling to have that going on with hardly any objections from fans, and it gave Amon the perfect example of how "benders abuse their power". Of course, he may have planned it that way, but if that's the case, I'd prefer if there was a more obvious indication that he or other Equalists had been the ones who paid off the refs.
>> No. 113625
>>113624
I agree. Believe it or not, it's things like that that really ruin my suspension of disbelief. I can accept fantastical magical elements or whatever, but when a sort-of-normal situation just goes completely against common sense, it's really jarring.
>> No. 113626
Amon obviously paid the refs off.

Also, there are few to no rules on what to do if a referee is perceived as biased during a match. Most sports take the referee being impartial as a given.
>> No. 113627
>>113624

I take it you've never watched an NBA playoffs game where all the refs fuck up a critical call in crunch time? The players effected can't do shit about it without penalizing their team (technical fouls issued for calling out the refs' shitty calls - or retaliating against the opponent taking physical liberties - two technical fouls on one player in a game = ejection). That's the predicament the Fire Ferrets were in, right in the heat of a championship match. They had to suck up the shitty/corrupt refs and battle on as best they can.

Speaking of corrupt refs IRL, there's assholes like this guy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tim_Donaghy
>> No. 113631
>>113627
I'm not a huge sports fan, really, though I watch some once in a while. That said, I've seen refs make bad calls. But can you imagine an NBA playoff game where the other team is blatantly shoving other players into each other, tripping them, hitting or kicking them, traveling, lifting each other up to make easy dunks, AND all of this happening with little more than a passing remark here and there from the commentators? No. The opposing fans would likely tear the place apart if nothing was done.

Now, if their cheating had been more subtle, maybe I could accept that. If it was hard to say for sure what was going on, you could come up with any number of excuses. But using ice and throwing water with rocks in it was definitely noticeable, especially when the last team was carried out on a stretcher with holes in their visors. At that point it was less of a competition and more of a one-sided battle. The announcer even said he hoped the Fire Ferrets knew a good doctor after that brutal match was over.
>> No. 113634
>>113631

The Sacramento Kings still haven't recovered from the blatant screwjob they got in 2002 vs. the Lakers. In that case it was blatant, called out by live broadcasters, and a national story afterward. As crazy as it sounds, this stuff really happens.
>> No. 113636
why do people even watch sports if they're that much of a joke?
>> No. 113642
The Aftermath

http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40362-the-legend-of-korra-vlogs-the-aftermath
>> No. 113644
>>113636
That alcohol ain't gonna drink itself.
>> No. 113645
>>113636
Tribalism.
>> No. 113647
>>113642
Well, I'm disappointed that he didn't seem to like this episode much. I can understand his frustrations with the pacing, the love triangle, his desire to see more of Amon, and the need to compare LoK to ATLA, because I share some of those same sentiments. But for me, I thought this was the episode where things picked up a little. I even went and rewatched it right after, and felt it was as strong as ever. You get to see Lin and Tenzin in action against the Mechs, and it was nice to see Asami make a stand against her father even if it was predictable. It was also good to see her bond with Korra before the whole Hiroshi thing drove them apart for a while. And I liked seeing Korra set aside her feelings to encourage Mako to comfort Asami at the end of the episode.

Even though I don't mind Makorra as much as other fans, it was handled rather poorly, and I almost wished they had continued in this direction instead. The fandom bitched about Aang not learning to "let go" of Katara (even though it was proven later that the Avatar needs attachment to the world, instead of seeking detachment like the other Airbender monks), so it would have been nice to tackle that issue with Korra and see her learn to let Mako go so that he and Asami could be happy together. Oh well. I just hope Doug stays interested enough that he doesn't decide it's not worth watching Korra past the first season.
>> No. 113649
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40374-the-legend-of-korra-vlogs-when-extremes-meet

Looks like he loves it again.
>> No. 113650
>>113649
I'm eager to see his next vlog as I personally loathed the next episode.
>> No. 113653
>>113649
Glad he's back into it, but he seems to have taken Tarrlok at his word instead of realizing that those were ordinary citizens he was intimidating and wrongfully arresting, not Equalists.

>>113650
How could you possibly loathe that episode? For the shipping issues? Even then, the rest of it is really good.
>> No. 113657
>>113653
Yes, the shipping issues were terrible. No, Mako, gushing over another girl is not an appropriate thing to do in front of your girlfriend. But my biggest problem with that episode was the absolutely weak answer as to why Tarlok can bloodbend without a full moon. Tarlok can because his father could. His father could because... because. No secret, forbidden technique, no pact with a rogue spirit, not even Combustion Man's "enlarged third eye." They set it up as a really cool mystery that really got me intrigued and then just dropped that non-answer in my lap.

What was worse was the fact that, at the time, this looked like it was the end to that plot thread. We had our answer as to how Tarlok did it and why, and no hint was given that it would have any significance for the rest of the show. Now that I know it actually does come back (and is the answer to the show's biggest mystery), I have a bit less hatred for it, but it was still a stupid answer that was horribly executed and seriously rustled my jimmies.
>> No. 113658
>>113657
Man, your bloodbending beef is weak. People get stronger as generations pass. In 1945, it was thought to be completely impossible to run a 4 minute mile, now you're probably not even eligible for the Olympics if you can't do it.

Yakon happened to be born with a talent for bloodbending, and his offspring inherited it. It's really no bigger an issue than lightning bending being so much more common among firebenders now.
>> No. 113659
>>113657
>Tarlok can because his father could. His father could because... because. No secret, forbidden technique, no pact with a rogue spirit, not even Combustion Man's "enlarged third eye." They set it up as a really cool mystery that really got me intrigued and then just dropped that non-answer in my lap.

You really are picky, aren't you? Listen to what >>113658 said. It's already been established that bending is at least partially genetic. Yakone also trained the hell out of Tarrlok and Noatak, so it's not like he suddenly woke up one day and became a master Bloodbender. Don't let your speculations cloud your opinion so much when it turns out they weren't true.

>not even Combustion Man's "enlarged third eye."

That was a tattoo, and I'm pretty sure it had nothing to do with his ability. It was symbolic, much like Aang's Airbender tattoos.
>> No. 113660
>>113658
Really, the issue is that the the most powerful bending ability in the Avatar world short of spirit-bending, just sort of occurred. It'd be like a person being able to run around the whole world in 4 minutes just because they happened to be born and did some training.

Seriously, the power level of blood-bending is so ridiculous it's hard to swallow or be satisfied with the explanation that Yakone can do it whenever he wants without even any physical effort just because.
>> No. 113661
>>113660
But it's "powerful" in the sense that it's extra dangerous, not in the sense that it really seems like it should take a lot of bending "power." Honestly, bloodbending should logically be easier than Plantbending, because people are actually designed to move around like that, and plants for the most part aren't.

Bloodbending just has special status because it's one of the only bending disciplines which the writers have shown canon examples of being used for horror story level magic--theoretically, based solely on the amount of energy it would take compared to the amount of energy other things we've seen Benders do would take, Air Benders should be able to suck the air out of people's lungs to asphyxiate them, and earth benders ought to be able to break or control people's bones, but we just don't see them doing it.

Point is, Blood Bending doesn't seem like it would take any more energy or skill than Plant Bending, other than because it has arbitrarily been said to do so. If we accept the word of the writers that it was only possible with the added power of a full moon, then why shouldn't we accept the word of the writers that a couple of generations' worth of evolution was enough to overcome that issue?
>> No. 113662
>>113658
My beef isn't half as week as your... pork? Yakon was alive during A:TLA, or at least within a decade of it ending. That is a remarkable increase in public health, especially for a society with a life expectancy exceeding 100 years.

And that's another thing that really gets under my skin: people defending the show by saying that Yakon has a "gift" for bloodbending. That's like saying a water bending has a gift for bending morning dew. Bloodbending, as defined in the show, is just bending the water in a person's body. It's applied waterbending. There's no rational way a person could be born with a supernatural gift for it.

>>113659
I have no problem with Tarlok getting his ability from his father, I have a problem with his father getting his abilities for no reason. And the third eye thing came from what I heard was the official explanation, which I recognize comes from outside the series, so it's not a 100% sound counter-argument. However, we know next to nothing about Combustion Man at the end of the series, and it's implied by the tattoos, metal limbs, and crazy abilities that he has a crazy history. If Yakon had a special tattoo, a birthmark, a piece of jewelry, something, anything to imply that there is an actual reason for him to be amazing at bloodbending, it might sit better with me. But there isn't.

Again, not a perfect counter-example, but still a better example.
>> No. 113663
>>113661
>Honestly, bloodbending should logically be easier than Plantbending, because people are actually designed to move around like that, and plants for the most part aren't.
People would resist.

But technicalities and reality aside, narratively - which is all that really matters honestly - if you have an incredibly power, there should be a satisfying explanation of it.
>> No. 113664
>>113661
>Honestly, bloodbending should logically be easier than Plantbending, because people are actually designed to move around like that, and plants for the most part aren't.

That reasoning only holds water when you consider the physical mechanics of bloodbending and waterbending, and even then it kinda falls apart because the human body has bones, which would make it more difficult for a the bloodbender to outright 'twist' the body into whatever shape is desired, whereas plants are made of a less rigid structure which will break easier in the face of an opposing waterbender. Of course, even before you begin to consider that, you have remember that blood isn't the responsible for the control of muscles, which engender movement, so bloodbending shouldn't even grant you control over someone else's motor functions. The best you should be able to do is pick up, and otherwise move, an individual through brute force (like Amon lifting a wolf off the ground in the flashbacks), and even that should cause serious injury due tot he massive cellular damage because you're picking someone up by their cells, which should cause death incredibly quickly.

If we accept that bloodbending is physically impossible, then we have to look for some other mechanism by which it works. Logically, the best assumption is that it works through some spiritual means, since bending has already been proven to be at least spiritually based in nature. This also leads to a rather natural conclusion as to why bloodbending is harder than plantbending - humans have more of a spiritual presence than plants, and are thus harder to influence. Therefore, it takes more bending power to trump a human than it does a person.
>> No. 113665
File 137756712322.jpg - (34.28KB , 962x539 , Out of the Past.jpg )
113665
http://blip.tv/nostalgiacritic/legend-of-korra-vlogs-out-of-the-past-6633884
>> No. 113671
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40413-the-legend-of-korra-vlogs-turning-the-tides

Everybody's favorite brother is back for more!
>> No. 113672
File 137773972479.png - (364.11KB , 640x1176 , clip (2013-02-28 at 06_56_54).png )
113672
Some of this going on in the most recent episode
>> No. 113673
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40427-the-legend-of-korra-vlogs-skeletons-in-the-closet

Some criticisms of Iroh's character design, but they loved the exposition and Amon's backstory.
>> No. 113677
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40450-the-legend-of-korra-vlogs-endgame

And we're done. Some mixed thoughts on the final episode, but I think the criticisms are valid.
>> No. 113678
>>113677
I'd definitely say there was more good than bad in Korra, but like they said, there was quite a bit of things that just irked, fell flat or disappointed. It's a bad feeling to have at the end of a series, it weakens the climatic moments and leaves a sour taste.

So long as these guys talk about the show, I can stand them, but jesus they are fucking whiny and annoying otherwise.
>> No. 113679
>>113678

I haven't watched a single second of the Korra reviews. Someone please post in this thread when he finally posts his TLA video.
>> No. 113702
here you go:

http://blip.tv/nostalgiacritic/nc-the-last-airbender-6637022
>> No. 113703
File 137824237237.jpg - (38.03KB , 959x539 , spikespeigel.jpg )
113703
>>113702

>dat ShyamAmon promo

TREATS EVERYWHERE
>> No. 113706
File 137824408934.gif - (174.74KB , 150x200 , taptaptaptaptap.gif )
113706
>that Acapella version of the ATLA closing credits song at the end

BREAK THE HOLD DAMMIT, THAT MAN HAS A FAMILY
>> No. 113719
>>113702
I knew North would be referenced.
>> No. 113724
>I've never once even so much as grinned at this tools so called humor...

but god dammit man i was laughing the whole damn near 40 minutes of this review xD

good job Doug good job.
>> No. 113843
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/nostalgia-critic/40555-nostalgia-critic-commentary-the-last-airbender

Now with commentary!
>> No. 114011
I'm not the only one waiting to see if he uploads a review of the new episode, am I?
>> No. 114079
>>114011
Ask and you shall receive!

http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40635-the-legend-of-korra-vlogs-rebel-spirit-and-southern-lights
>> No. 114092
Of course the brother is there.

Maybe it won't be so bad since they're both watching ti at the same time.
>> No. 114227
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40667-the-legend-of-korra-vlogs-civil-wars-part-1
>> No. 114574
http://blip.tv/nostalgiacritic/legend-of-korra-vlogs-civil-wars-part-2-6648501
>backstory
>> No. 114578
I get their gripe as we've never had a flashback of Korra during her formative training years other than when she was first introduced as the Avatar. Course part of her obliviousness is that she's only been out and about for a little bit over a year. She's kinda like Conan in that respect powerful and skilled but very green as far as the world goes and very naive as to people motives until put right under her nose.
>> No. 114582
>>114578
I disagree.

True she was sheltered but she did have people to teach her basic manners and she should have been more than able to pick up on human intent from her instructors a lot of them seemed ill tempered and manipulative i just don't buy that whole shes never been around people b.s. yes making her rash is warranted by her nietivity is beyond ridiculous.

it really feels like korra is the lower priority to the writers who im guessing are afraid of making the side chars dull and cliche like most of them were last season.

they're pretty much just neglecting the main character so far. she's literally back to square one anyone who has been through that amon ordeal or similer shoulda know better.

Doug n Rob are patting themselves on the back but the truth is even a kid could call this b.s. I still have hopes for this season and despite its probs i loved the first. but the writers need to get on the damn ball.

I'm just chalking the uncle up to a bad joke that was meant to be so blatantly obvious.
>> No. 114585
>>114582
Uncle is still an unknown as we don't know his endgame, yea sure he's pretty much acting all Emperor but he's not revealed his whole hand yet. Overall Korra development and to an extent Asami I think is the result of Writing a Mini and then getting picked up for a full 52 and then having to rehash things in order for that to work.
>> No. 114624
dude i was positive while being true about my feelings so far. you on the other hand just seem to be sucking at the teet cause milk has to come out eventually right? stop wishful thinking and except it for what it is. "hasn't showed his hand yet" my ass! his story is already damn near over. anyone whose ever seen a backstabbing sibling arc can call that he'll attempt to frame korra in a similer matter. and I'm starting to agree with the people saying he's the chump baddie holding a place for the real big bad. (though i doubt grey's char is the main villain) but im not gonna make or except any excuses for the crummy writing so far. (don't read that wrong a lot of it is going great so far you know except the neglecting the main fucking character part) and if that is what they did with asami and korra then that kinda feels like they don't even want to acknowledge the first season or its fuck ups (outside the 2 main plot references so far anyways.) which imo is a bad move they need to admit it and fix it by building onto the already etchy plot instead of poking fun at it and otherwise pretty much ignoring it. also did anyone else feel that during the scene between the brothers, asami was pretty much a blank slate on the whole subject? that was the perfect time to address mako dumping her like that. but its like she wasn't even there? she even had a blank stare on her face. hell everyone in the room while we were watching said shit to mako when he said that line about bolin's gf troubles not being his fault. asami was right there in reality i'm sure she woulda had plenty to say. it was as if they didn't even try to acknowledge it. that coulda given us some advancement to season ones plot but they really don't even seem to want to touch that subject anymore than they'll have to. I mean fuck if anything there should have atleast been some reactive glares directed at mako in at least half that dialog.
>> No. 114941
Still no "Peacekeepers" video?
>> No. 114954
>>114941
Maybe they re-watched their reaction and realized that they should have done something more than fangirl over Basco for twenty minutes.
>> No. 115052
Okay. This is the first one I found myself disliking. Their constant claiming that characters must change makes me angry. Who told them everyone must change?

Those two really need to watch some Cowboy Bebop. Spike was awesome because he did not change.
>> No. 115083
>>115052
Yes, because there is an obvious parallel between Korra (a hotheadded teenage girl tasked with an awesome responsibility) and Spike (a laid-back adult man with a mysterious past who lives outside the law). They're practically the same person with completely identical character arcs. And both of their shows have jazz in them.
>> No. 115235
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/40928-legend-of-korra-vlogs-the-sting
>> No. 115236
>>115083
You're missing the point. Their entire premise is faulty, and Spike is evidence of how their premise is faulty. Korra doesn't have to be similar to Spike because no one's comparing her to Spike--they're just saying that the supposed Critic doesn't really understand literary theory beyond an amateur level.
>> No. 115239
>>115235
I hear them but I don't understand their complaints. Still don't understand what the deal is giving Korra a hard time for being bullheaded and "stupid" nor do I understand why to call her such.
>> No. 115290
>>115236
Except they never made the claim that all main characters need to progress and develop. All they said was that the characters in this specific show need to develop.
>> No. 115546
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/41034-legend-of-korra-vlogs-beginnings-1-a-2

"The Legend of Korra: Gets to the Point"
>> No. 115547
File 138241247785.png - (279.01KB , 460x610 , yeeesss nitpicking gives you strength.png )
115547
>>115546
I don't like this guy.
>> No. 115548
>>115547
You wouldn't be the first. I think he's alright. I have a soft spot for brothers talking about the stuff they watched as I do that with my brother all the time.
>> No. 115550
>>115546
I do kinda agree that this special should have been what kicked off the season sans the Korra intro to it as it would have been a good lead and led to speculation as to why the spirits were acting the way the were. But would have added to the "Korra is stupid" yadda when she opens the portal and other things since the same people would be bitching about what she should know.
>> No. 115552
>>115547
He bothered me a lot more during the ATLA reviews. Yeah, it's still kind of annoying having him in EVERY Korra review now, but he's actually gotten a lot better. I was laughing a little when he made the Gozer comparison in this review. If he just holds back a little more and doesn't interrupt Doug so much, he's tolerable. And he was doing really good at memorizing/pronouncing the names lately, although he screwed up on "ukiyo-e" toward the end. They're still both giving Korra too hard a time, IMO, but I think now they're getting into it more. Hopefully the next few episodes will kick things into gear and start improving so we'll all have less to complain about.
>> No. 115930
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/41282-legend-of-korra-vlogs-the-guide-and-a-new-spiritual-age

A two-fer.
>> No. 116331
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/41475-legend-of-korra-vlogs-finale

And we're done with season 2!
>> No. 116338
why does Korra's personality seem to be such a sticking point with some?
>> No. 116343
>>116338

Because it hits too close to home to the average overemotional fan.

The one difference is that while Korra is badass for it, the haters only achieve manchildren status.

Also strong women being intimidating to misogynists or whatever.
>> No. 116350
>>116343
really hope that bit I saw in one post about "the only way to do it right would be to remove her gender." was just trolling.
>> No. 116354
>>116343
Are you one of those fans who says that any problem a viewer has with the show must be their own fault? Because there are plenty of legitimate complaints to be made here.

Korra can be badass, but she can also be impulsive, reckless, and narrow-minded. There were several times in this season when she ignored the blatantly obvious and made irrational decisions because she was angry. Watching a character being stupid gets viewers annoyed.
>> No. 116373
>>116354
Of course there are legitimate reasons to just plain dislike her character, but for Korra (and some other, usually female, characters) there also exists this exaggerated, intense hate that you can't help but think comes from somewhere personal. You know, the same stuff in the vein of those raving rants that may involve misuse of the word mary sue.
>> No. 116375
>>116354
>Watching a character being stupid gets viewers annoyed.

Speak for yourself. I'm able to accept that some characters, godlove'em, just ain't that bright. And I like them despite it.
>> No. 116381
>>116373
Well, as this thread exists specifically for discussing Doug and Rob Walker's reviews of the show and they have not shown any kind of exaggerated hatred for Korra, I don't see the relevance.

>>116375
I like SpongeBob because he's stupid. I like Michael Scott because he's stupid. I like Andy Dwyer because he's stupid. Heck, I liked Sokka because he could occasionally be stupid. Stupid people make for some great comedy. But when a character makes stupid decisions in serious situations, I get very frustrated. I see that as a lazy way of adding extra threat to the story. "And our hero refused to listen to the sound logic presented to her by a loved one and insisted that her initial assumption was correct and anyone who says otherwise was against her" does not make for enjoyable drama in my eyes.
>> No. 116382
File 138602898564.jpg - (191.07KB , 720x480 , fire12-96.jpg )
116382
>>116381

>"And our hero refused to listen to the sound logic presented to her by a loved one and insisted that her initial assumption was correct and anyone who says otherwise was against her" does not make for enjoyable drama in my eyes.
>> No. 116383
>>116382

OHHHHHHH WHAT A BURN!!

On his face.
>> No. 116384
>>116381
>>116382
>"And our hero refused to listen to the sound logic presented to her by a loved one and insisted that her initial assumption was correct and anyone who says otherwise was against her"
Also known as "Acting like a teenager."
>> No. 116426
>>116381
You're right, it's a derail. I got distracted since that question said "some people".
[Return] [Entire Thread] [Last 50 posts] [First 100 posts]


Delete post []
Password  
Report post
Reason