/a/ Avatar Archived Board plus4chan home [baw] [co/cog/jam/mtv] [coc/draw/diy] [pco/coq/cod] [a/mspa/op/pkmn] [Burichan/Futaba/Greygren]
[Return] [Entire Thread] [Last 50 posts] [First 100 posts]
Posting mode: Reply
Name
Email
Subject   (reply to 112202)
Message
File
Password  (for post and file deletion)

Currently 0 unique user posts.

News
  • 08/21/12 - Poll ended; /cod/ split off as a new board from /pco/.

File 137013441459.png - (566.58KB , 750x419 , Untitled.png )
112202 No. 112202
Doug Walker (AKA The Nostalgia Critic) has decided to review Syamalan's masterpiece, but he wants to come at it knowing about the source material, so he's going to be watching the entire series, one episode per night, and posing his reactions and thoughts in video form. As a big fan of his work (less so since his comeback) and of his reviews, I'm super excited and can't wait to see his thoughts.

http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39420-the-last-airbender-vlogs

Who will be watching with me?
Expand all images
>> No. 112203
Whoa! The NC stuff has inevitably gotten a little stale, but I won't miss this.
>> No. 112204
can someone hotlink them in this thread plz?
>> No. 112205
I've never really seen the point of professional review videos.
>> No. 112206
You have my attention.
>> No. 112207
Hopefully this'll be better then the crap that was Disneycember and Dreamworksuary
>> No. 112209
>>112204
I'm sure they'll be posted under the "Specials" section of his site.

http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials
>> No. 112212
File 137015863874.png - (283.80KB , 442x628 , 1356567796132.png )
112212
I'm looking forward to this with optimism. Cautious optimism. But I'm sure he'll enjoy the series overall. I just dread what will happen when he gets around to reviewing the Crime Against Cinema that is the movie. I'm picturing the "Horribifuckus" montage from when he tried to watch TMNT 3, which was pretty much the first thing that popped into my head when I saw clips from ShamWow's TLA.
>> No. 112215
A review of each episode could be interesting. I wonder if he'll complain about the gaps that were filled by the comics (in the cartoons the Earth King just sort of disappears, while in the comics they explain that he's on a journey to learn about the world).
>> No. 112216
>>112215

Sokka mentions that in Season 3, actually.
>> No. 112217
Sounds fun.

If anyone's hungry for something similar, I'd recommend the recap SF Debris did of Korra's first season. It covered all the bases.

http://sfdebris.com/videos/animation/lok.asp
>> No. 112218
IT BEGINS

http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39436-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-boy-in-the-iceberg
>> No. 112220
Someone ought to tell him some of the episodes are supposed to be watched back to back
>> No. 112221
>>112205
>I've never really seen the point of professional review videos.
I can't speak for others, but I just enjoy listening to people's opinions when they know how to voice them.

>>112218
I love how he pegs Iroh's entire character in the first episode. That's the sign of a well-written and well-acted role.
>> No. 112222
File 137023524415.png - (301.53KB , 289x533 , punkdrugs.png )
112222
>>112220

>He only watched half of the premiere

D'oh!
>> No. 112224
>>112203
This.
I'll stick around.

>>112207
And hey! I liked those.

Hell, those are the reason why he's doing these anyway.
He started out Disneycember. Then did it again, then noticed how Profitable december was views-wise.
Being the main draw to the site, people checked back ever day. Giving the site pagevisits, increasing the value of advertising space, and increasing ad revenue.
Then did it again with dreamworks, and now he's doing this.
An just as established franchise with alot of content and a strong and large fanbase.
Don't be surprised if once he's done he starts thinking about doing homestuck.

Frankly, the guy is a pretty savvy businessguy when it comes to internet stuff.
>> No. 112225
I liked the review of the first one, and that he seems to be approaching it was a more open mind than I've seen some people use.

Some people just hate the show on principle due to it either "ripping off anime" or "being an anime" regardless of the actual content. Both arguements are stupid.

Looking forward to the rest, is it a daily thing or a weekly thing?

>>112203

I'm not sure about stale, but the new episodes do seem to have more genuine resentment behind them than the previous ones. Like before you could tell he was playing a character, but now it seems more like Doug himself is getting kind of sick of things.

Or maybe he's just that good an actor, I don't know. I've liked some of the renewed stuff, but I thought that the character had a good ending with TBF and the rest, honestly.
>> No. 112228
>>112224
When Doug did Disneycember, he missed the damn point of why Monster Madness was so appealing. James Rolfe actually knew his shit about the history of horror and had this passion for it that made it interesting to watch the series and you'd actually learn something from it. Disneycember basically amounted to bland "I like this, I don't like this, this was mediocre, the animation was colorful" comments, offering no unique insight and it ended up being pretty meh.
>> No. 112230
It's been a while since I've seen someone watch the series with a fresh outlook. Personally I always thought season 1 takes a while to get started so it'll be interesting to see his take on it. Someone should also tell him the movie is only based on S1.

>>112228
When he did Disneycember you could tell he was actually excited, and was tapping into his own nostalgia of the older movies. But during the Dreamworks reviews he sounded more like a parent who had just seen the films, just mentioning what was funny or good for kids.
>> No. 112232
>>112225
>Looking forward to the rest, is it a daily thing or a weekly thing?
He says he'll post a video every night whenever he's able to. He has to travel a lot for cons and such, so don't be surprised if he misses a couple of days.

If it was weekly, it would take about a year to get through the whole series.
>> No. 112238
next one is up.
>> No. 112239
>>112238

It's only the second video, but I'm getting a bit annoyed that he's not referring to the characters by name.
>> No. 112240
File 137031901853.jpg - (3.18KB , 190x200 , RVD_WAT.jpg )
112240
I want to choke some of the idiots in the comments

> avatar
Sokka and Aang have always been my least liked characters. As Doug points out humor is very hit-or-miss and Sokka - at least to me - is full of miss. He's meant to be the comic relief but a lot of the time he's just annoying. His slapstick antics constantly raise the question; "what purpose do you serve in this group?" I'll give the writers this though; as the series progressed he actually became less useless, though still unfunny.

>Aang is boring. Typical god-hero, his character arc ultimately boiling down to "will he discover how perfect he is before the final battle," the answer to which is pretty obvious since it's a kids show. Obviously he's not going to lose. It's up to the writers to make the character interesting despite how transparent his journey is, but because they've already established him as an all around good person there aren't many places his arc can go. Zuko is far more interesting, as Doug will find as he further delves into the series.

This person is too fucking stupid to live- hey wait a second!

>username: KaizerJED

Is this...is this Serial Kiffer? The same shithead behind the OMG GRIMDARK AU that was secretly dedicated to the Insane Clown Posse?
>> No. 112241
>>112240
>Sokka and Aang have always been my least liked characters.
In that case, you have a bad opinion.
>> No. 112244
>>112228
Sure.
But in the end, this guy's working for profit.

James Rolf has as well, but..
He's always felt more authentic. Doing stuff out of love for videogames, film making...
I don't wanna pass judgement on this guy, but he just seems to roll with whatever brings in cash.
>> No. 112245
>>112241
Well no shit, it's Serial Kiffer. He's like...objectively wrong. As a person.
>> No. 112250
http://blip.tv/nostalgiacritic/the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-avatar-returns-6597046
As expected, he's now hooked.
>> No. 112252
Gooooood.

It's going to make the review kind of hilarious when the internal logic of the show was lost somewhere in the making of the movie.

Such as the prison episode. Or the natural relationship growth of Sokka/Yue.
>> No. 112253
*When the review shows how the internal logic and character progression was lost, I mean, Argh.
>> No. 112254
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39465-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-southern-air-temple

The agni kai in this episode is one of my all-time favorite moments in this series. So glad he loved it for all the same reasons I did.

I do, however, fear that he's setting himself up for a bit of a letdown when he gets to the slower episodes of this season. It's not all amazing, Doug. It's never bad, but it does stray from amazing from time to time.
>> No. 112255
>>112254

The high points of the first half of the season are the premier, the Southern air temple, imprisoned and the winter solstice two-parter.

He has enough to keep him going until he hits the storm ,and it's mostly up from there.
>> No. 112256
>8 years since the show premiered.

man I feel old.
>> No. 112257
>honor
He gets it!
>> No. 112258
>>112255
The Blue Spirit's pretty good, too.
>> No. 112259
>>112254
Should someone warn him about "The Great Divide"?

Like just tell him to skip it, or close his eyes and mute the show and think of something else for 22 minutes?
>> No. 112260
>>112259

No lie, that was my very first Avatar episode and it's not absolutely horrible, (though being unfamiliar with the series at the time, I had thought Aang wasn't totally human, thus the "I may not look it but I'm 112 years old!")
>> No. 112261
>>112260
Honestly, I liked it better than The Beach.
>> No. 112262
>>112259
I swear to God I'm the only person who genuinely loves that episode.

It's not the best episode by any means, but I like it.
>> No. 112263
>>112259
The Great Divide is far from terrible - mediocre, and not up the general quality of the rest of the show, but it's blown out of proportion.

It's worth watching through the first time, at least, and skipping if you find it dull.
>> No. 112264
>>112260
Same thing here, The Great Divide was the first episode. It makes a good case for showing off different animation styles and the different kind of peoples in the Avatar world.

I know people hate The Great Divide but at least to me, they seem to exaggerate the flaws in the episode.
>> No. 112265
>>112225
>Some people just hate the show on principle due to it either "ripping off anime" or "being an anime" regardless of the actual content. Both arguements are stupid.

They're also ironic because the anime style was based on old Disney cartoons.
>> No. 112266
The Great Divide gets loads of hate because the series was on a hiatus and it's the only episode they showed for a stretch of several weeks.
>> No. 112268
As a person whose very first episode of AtLA was The Great Divide, I'll just say that that episode put me off the show for about two years before my friends managed to convince me to give AtLA another try.

So yeah, it's that bad.
>> No. 112270
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39473-the-last-airbender-vlogs-warriors-of-kyoshi

Foamy Mouth Guy claims another fan.
>> No. 112271
File 137057327836.jpg - (100.19KB , 930x478 , Avatar__crazy_foamy_guy_by_rufftoon.jpg )
112271
Foamy get's the creed he deserves.
>> No. 112273
File 137057422368.jpg - (26.48KB , 299x419 , 1310709622073.jpg )
112273
>He is liking it a lot

>He has to review the movie.

He found Avatar, but at what cost...
>> No. 112274
>>112270
Wow, Avatar brings families together. That's sweet.

>>112273
His rage in approximately two months will be delicious. It will likely dwarf anything James Rolfe has managed to produce.
>> No. 112275
Now that I realize, the naming of the creatures was pretty inconsistent in the beginning.

When did the half/half mixture establish itself?
>> No. 112276
File 13705806255.jpg - (8.10KB , 200x193 , katara_dowant.jpg )
112276
>>112270

GOT 'EM
>> No. 112277
To be honest, I never much liked Warriors of Kiyoshi. I found the girl power subplot rather irritating. But Doug does make a good point in how it's handled better than in other works. I'm glad he enjoyed it.

The only possible stumbling blocks from here to the season finale are The Great Divide and The Fortuneteller. Think he'll find a way to sail over those as being good in some way? I never hated The Great Divide, despite it's superfluousness, but the whole Reason vs. Faith debate in The Fortuneteller was pretty annoying.
>> No. 112278
>he doesn't get the lettuce leaf joke

I am appalled and disappointed.
>> No. 112279
>>112278
What kind of wizard are you, I don't even see it up on the site yet?
>> No. 112280
>>112279
Takes time to set up the embed on their main site.

http://blip.tv/nostalgiacritic/the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-king-of-omashu-6599349
>> No. 112281
>>112280
Well... ok, but I still think your some kind of dark wizard regardless.
>> No. 112282
Well, hopefully he'll watch the Winter Solstice together, since it's says part 1 and 2 on the very title.
>> No. 112283
http://blip.tv/nostalgiacritic/the-last-airbender-vlogs-imprisoned-6599967
>> No. 112289
File 137076254984.jpg - (50.18KB , 960x541 , duhhoii.jpg )
112289
>>112283

>He's getting all 3 main character's names down
>He fucking loves Geroge Takei's character and performance
>He loves the episode
>He's getting sucked in, a happy sucked in, not a depressing 'Game of Thrones' kind of sucked in

Good Goodyoutube thumb
>> No. 112297
http://blip.tv/nostalgiacritic/the-last-airbender-vlogs-winter-solstice-1-2-6600336
>> No. 112298
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39507-the-last-airbender-vlogs-winter-solstice-1-a-2
>> No. 112300
File 137083883579.jpg - (7.60KB , 177x278 , ohbaby.jpg )
112300
>he watched both parts of the two parter

He's learning.
>> No. 112302
File 137084005761.gif - (1.26MB , 163x200 , 1370486478492.gif )
112302
>dat observance of the directing of the closing shot of part 2

Delectable.

gif attached is a response for this dumb-as-rocks commentor

>Blizzard185 - To Freyzi:
>The ONLY episode I don't like watching out of this entire show was the Season 3 episode "Ember Island Players".

>hating the most glorious episode of the series
>> No. 112303
File 137084135089.png - (1.03MB , 1280x720 , vlcsnap-2013-06-09-03h31m02s245.png )
112303
>>112289
Higher quality:
>> No. 112304
>>112300
To be fair, the first two episodes weren't listed as Part 1 and Part 2.
>> No. 112321
File 137095014118.png - (526.02KB , 720x576 , phf.png )
112321
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39521-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-waterbending-scroll

>"So the lemur can fly? When was that a thing?"
>my face
>> No. 112324
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39528-the-last-airbender-vlogs-jet
>> No. 112334
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39537-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-great-divide
weeeeeeelp
>> No. 112335
>>112334

>8+ minutes railing on the ending of the episode

Really? THAT is what turned him off in the Great Divide? REALLY?
>> No. 112337
File 137113569572.jpg - (172.97KB , 940x746 , PutYourHandsUp.jpg )
112337
Hey! Why doesn't Imprisoned get jazz hands in it's thumbnail preview like all the rest!?
>> No. 112338
>The storm is up next

I predict a 20+ min video.
>> No. 112341
File 137114115567.png - (649.19KB , 720x540 , vlcsnap-2011-10-14-01h47m06s212.png )
112341
>>112334
Some people are still butthurt about their parents lying to them a long long time ago, and just cannot get over it. That's why so many people disliked the episode. Mommy lied to be about Santa! Waaaaaaah!

To be fair, ^that IS something to be upset about.

In defense of the episode, I just cannot see the conflict getting resolved any other way. It is clear that both tribes only care about what happened in the past. The don't want to move on, they don't want to forget. Their lives are controlled by their tradition and myths. Kind of reminds me of americans always debating over just what "the founding fathers" wanted. Since they could only stop fighting if a myth from their past told them so, Aang made one up.

tl;dr they were too stupid to accept the truth, so Aang had to use his trollbending (probably taught to him by Gyatso)
>> No. 112342
Nowhere it says the Avatar has to be perfect. Being human is about making mistakes and learning from it.

Remember when Aang stole a map showing Hakoda's fleet meeting point?
>> No. 112343
>>112342
Then there was that time he raped and killed a girl in 1990... oh wait, that was Glenn Beck.
>> No. 112345
>>112335

Ikr? That was one of the few things I actually liked about that episode (backgrounds, creature design, and the canyon guide being the others). The ending joke was actually pretty funny and I thought helped highlight just how bullshit and stupid their feud was.

In fact, the main reason I don't like this episode is that it all feels so blatant and preachy. Leaving Aang's story as true would have just given it an even worse pre-school lesson time feel.

I don't want to have my only comment on this stuff negative, so I'll say I'm really actually enjoying these vlogs. He's usually really insightful about the show and has noted some things I never really thought about. Plus it's really fun to watch his enthusiasm. I'm a little surprised to tell the truth since I got sick of his Nostalgia Critic stuff forever ago (though I'm guessing his NC review of TLA will be amazing).
>> No. 112346
I wonder if he'll keep going on through to Korra.
>> No. 112347
>>112346
It's still too early to tell, but let's hope he does.
>> No. 112351
>>112335
Heh Doug can't handle fables can he.

>>112346
Wonder if the more modern type setting would pull him out.
>> No. 112352
Oh Doug, how much are you going to suffer in the crossroads of destiny.
>> No. 112353
http://blip.tv/nostalgiacritic/the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-storm-6602364

>"There's one character especially when the uncles watching.. ...and there's this one girl in the front, I think there gonna make her a character, I'd be shocked if they didn't because she's just too well designed, and she just has this look, this evil little smile..."

Oh Doug, I'm now heavily anticipating you getting to that scene at the very end of the first season season.
>> No. 112355
>>112353
wonder what he'll think of the beach episode.
>> No. 112357
>>112353
Good God this guys fans are shitty. Doug makes mention of noticing that girl with the grin during the Agni Kai and half the comments are...

>OMG!!!! That's Azula!! THat's totally Zuko's sister who shows up a the end of the season and is the bad guy from season 2 on, and let me give you the rest of her bio and lay out all the plot points for which she's involved!!!

The fuck?
>> No. 112358
>>112357

Christ. Now I totally get Mark's spoiler-Nazi approach when he did his reviews.

Like a huge part of the fun of this is seeing his reaction to stuff as a newcomer. Why would they want to ruin that by telling him everything that happens? Luckily he said in his intro that he wasn't going to read many comments.
>> No. 112361
http://blip.tv/nostalgiacritic/the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-blue-spirit-6602896
I love how he guessed Azula's importance and age but was completely clueless about the Blue Spirit's identity.
>> No. 112362
>>112361
>Blue Demon

He's not kidding, he really is terrible at remembering episode names.
>> No. 112364
File 137126889468.gif - (955.02KB , 294x195 , stabbystab.gif )
112364
>>112361

>people in the comments calling The Fortunteller a filler episode

Get fucked with a rusty chainsaw pls
>> No. 112365
>>112364
There's this thing on the internet, where armchair critics have heard the term "filler" and don't really understand what it means, so they apply it willy-nilly even where it doesn't apply, like they do with Mary Sue and Hipster, to the point that it becomes meaningless. Really, outside of an work that's an adaptation from one medium to another, it's "filler" isn't really a thing that can exist.

But even if it were, it's not supposed to refer to episodes that advance a character's emotional arc or provide reduced tension for the sake of pacing and characterization. If it were, you would have to refer to pretty much the entirety of Cowboy Bebop as "filler," since there are only about four "plot" episodes in the entire series. That is not how filler works. Filler is supposed to have no relation to the rest of the work. Even if the only effect that an episode has is that it foreshadows something that happens later, or sets the audience's expectations about how a character behaves so that a later character moment has the appropriate amount of emotional torque, it's not filler.

Sometimes the fact that "nothing happens" (which is impossible, but people who focus on plot over character have a bad habit of not being able to see the forest for the trees) is important to the story that's being told.
>> No. 112366
File 137127608414.png - (1.24MB , 1280x720 , vlcsnap-2013-06-15-01h56m35s66.png )
112366
>>112361
And 3 more.
>> No. 112367
File 137127617086.png - (1.17MB , 1280x720 , vlcsnap-2013-06-15-01h58m21s204.png )
112367
>>112366
>> No. 112368
File 137127621735.png - (1.31MB , 1280x720 , vlcsnap-2013-06-15-01h59m09s140.png )
112368
>>112367
>> No. 112369
File 13712762755.png - (1.22MB , 1280x720 , vlcsnap-2013-06-15-01h59m53s205.png )
112369
>>112368
>> No. 112374
File 137136312685.jpg - (97.45KB , 600x568 , critic unitinu.jpg )
112374
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39571-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-fortuneteller
>> No. 112382
He posts a new review every day. Why are you ppl so slow?
>> No. 112387
>>112382
Hold yer damn horses, Mister...

http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39583-the-last-airbender-vlogs-bato-of-the-water-tribe

So apparently he didn't think The Great Divide was that bad (apart from the ending), but Bato of the Water Tribe was the first episode he didn't really like. Admittedly, the conflict between the Gaang members in this episode is a little contrived, but as Doug himself likes to point out, they are still kids.
>> No. 112393
>>112387
I'm not really a big fan of Bato of the Water Tribe either, but I absolutely love the fight scene between Aang and Zuko. It's the first time the two really spend an extended amount of time duking it out. The choreography is amazing and you can really see the clash of their personalities through their fighting style. Although it's sort of limiting, I really liked how the show made the connection between personality and fighting style so clear.
>> No. 112397
>>112387
It's because he hates anything with a Liar Revealed pllot.
>> No. 112399
File 137153766661.png - (294.00KB , 478x258 , DBry.png )
112399
>Liking most of The Great Divide aside from just the ending
>Hating Bato of the Water Tribe

ISHIGGYDIGGY
>> No. 112400
File 137153801674.jpg - (7.93KB , 195x258 , ruffleshaveridges.jpg )
112400
>thinking Bato just contrively 'switched sides' after the Gaang confict

Bato just put the gaang through a Rite of Passage to adulthood. He was treating the water sibs as equals, not as an authority figure.

Doug tends to let these things go right over his head. This rustles muh jimmies.
>> No. 112404
ok so why has it been silent for 3 days now?
>> No. 112408
File 137169868631.gif - (2.00MB , 389x157 , screamandpanic.gif )
112408
>>112404
HE SAW THE NEXT EPISODE AND HATED IT SO MUCH THAT HE CALLED OFF THE ENTIRE SERIES!
>> No. 112409
>>112408

>hating the deserter
>> No. 112421
http://thatguywiththeglasses.com/videolinks/thatguywiththeglasses/specials/39631-the-last-airbender-vlogs-the-deserter

Just kidding!
343 posts omitted. First 100 shown. [Return] [Entire Thread] [Last 50 posts] [First 100 posts]


Delete post []
Password  
Report post
Reason