plus4chan
ImageboardsRadio
Site Theme...
imageboards
Main FAQ [ baw] [ co / cog / jam / mtv / tek ] [ ck / coc / draw / writ ] [ pco / coq ] [ a / op / pkmn ] [ n ]
Long-Term Projects

 Posting a reply to post #21348
Name
Email
Subject  
Message
File 
Password  


File: 126344310881.png-(62.08KB, 1750x550, Scarab.png)
21348 No.21348
Pictured are four itinerations of the same character, Scarab, with each inineration being more armored than the one preceding it. If you would, please tell me which design you prefer, and why you prefer it that way. Another option, not shown, is itineration #4 without the shoulder armor. I could quickly make that up, if you require a visual example. Thank you in advance for your help.

Expand all images
No.21351
I prefer 4 but 3 is nice too. Four just looks more balanced over all.

No.21352
>>21351
Thank you! I appreciate your comment. I was worried that the chest armor might detract from the sleek look that I was going for. Do you believe this fear to be unfounded?

No.21353
File: 126345368415.png-(39.93KB, 550x550, Scarab4.png)
21353
Here is Scarab with the chest armor but without the shoulder ornamentation.

No.21355
>>21353
that looks good too, it has a sleeker look but also has enough bulk to the chest to balance out the boots

No.21356
>>21355
Have you changed your preference, then, to the most recent one?

No.21358
>>21356
no, but the new one doesn't look bad either

No.21383
>>21358
So we still like the most armored version, then? Very good, thank you for your help.

Does anyone else want to weigh in?

No.21385
File: 126348894249.png-(68.33KB, 2070x550, The Scarab.png)
21385
Here's another single image with all of the itinerations on it, for easy perusal. I'd love to hear people's opinions.

No.21394
I think the chest armor make him more sleek, as long as the shoulder pads are not pointed (the round shoulder pads are OK)

>>21353
looks the sleekest.

The one without armor looks like Generic Superhero In Tights #47

The shoulder pads change that, but I like the chest armor because of the third red circle that goes along with the circles on his arms. Might be cool if they were his Scarab logo, if you want to go there.

No.21399
>>21394
So, one vote for the moderately-armored look, without shoulder armor. Thanks much!

No.21400
The red circle draws the viewer's eye in without distracting them from the rest of his body.

No.21402
So then, 1-3 aren't bulky enough, five is too bulky, and four looks to be just about perfect?

No.21403
I vote for #4, or >>21353. Seems the most balanced overall.

No.21407
>>21403
I concur.



Main FAQ [ baw] [ co / cog / jam / mtv / tek ] [ ck / coc / draw / writ ] [ pco / coq ] [ a / op / pkmn ] [ n ]
0.0066659450531006 (0.01 seconds )